Versace Eros vs Eros Flame vs Eros EDP [Comparison 2024]

Written By John Carter

Versace Eros is considered one of the best party scents. But the confusion begins when Versace releases two more flankers of Eros.

But, If you haven’t tried any one of them yet, then which cologne should you get?

Finding the answer to this can be very frustrating as they all have different features.

Don’t worry! After testing these colognes on myself, I have figured out the similarities and differences. It’ll help you to choose your desired one.

So, without wasting any more time, let’s see which cologne comes out with a victory in this battle.

Versace Eros vs Versace Eros Flame vs Versace Eros EDP

Eros EDT vs Eros Flame vs Eros EDP: Which is the best smelling cologne?

Versace Eros was released in 2012, and the nose behind this fragrance was Aurelien Guichard.

Versace Eros is a party monster. The loud scent profile of Eros is widely admired and loved. And the sensual touch in this cologne is so perfect and clean.

In 2018, Olivier Pescheux came with a flanker of Eros called Eros Flame. The bottle design is similar, but the color of the bottle is red; which goes well with the name, I’d say.

Versace Eros Flame is basically focused on spices. It’s youthful, delegate, and sweeter.

Versace Came with the EDP version of Eros in 2020. This version of Eros is smoother and delicious. And in a short time, this scent gathered so much love.

Versace Eros vs Eros Flame vs Eros EDP

As you can see, These fragrances have qualities that make you spend a good amount of money on them.

But, these are also very different scents, with different notes and effects on people.

So, how to know which cologne has better performance, and which will better value your money? Read on to find the answers.

So, here is the comparison of  Versace Eros, Eros Flame, and Eros EDP:

Opening

In the case of Versace Eros, they used mint, green apple, and lemon in the opening. It gives a very fresh and rich opening. The sweetness is balanced, and the fruity touch is impressive. You’ll definitely love the opening of Versace Eros.

On the other hand, Eros Flame used mandarin orange, black pepper, chinotto, lemon, and rosemary. The opening of Eros Flame is citrusy and spicy. But the initial blast of citrus notes is fantastic, and it gives an instant freshness. The sweetness in this cologne is balanced and refreshing.

As we can see, Eros EDP used mint, candy apple, lemon, and mandarin orange in the opening. The opening of Eros EDP is almost like the opening of Eros. But the citrus dominates here. And Versace managed to provide a suitable amount of freshness and sweetness in this cologne.

Though Eros Flame’s opening is fantastic, the opening of Eros was the best to me.

But, that was before I sniffed Eros EDP. The recently added EDP version can beat the opening of Versace Eros.

Quickly check out our post on D&G Light Blue vs Light Blue Eau Intense

Now, which is better?

Clearly, the winner here is Eros EDP. Though it’s a personal preference, it’s really rare to find an opening like Eros. And Eros EDP just added a different touch, which is mind-blowing.

In my opinion, Among these three, Eros EDP has the best opening.

Projection And Longevity

Versace Eros series is famous for it’s insane projection and longevity. As all of these fragrances use rich notes, as a result, they all provide fantastic projection and longevity. The performance level of these fragrances is almost similar.

Versace Eros starts with a minty-sweet projection, and after some time, it tempers down and lasts an entire day. It’ll undoubtedly help you to improve your mood.

Moreover, the sweetness level is balanced and delightful. It’s one of the best party fragrances which projects a lot to attract people.

On the other hand, Eros Flame starts with a spicy-citrusy opening, and soon it becomes sweeter and lasts for an entire day. The projection level of Eros Flame is also fantastic. It’ll always try to keep you noticed in a huge crowd.

Undoubtedly, Eros Flame will be a remarkable fragrance for you just for its performance.

And lastly, if we talk about Eros EDP, it’ll satisfy you in every way it can. The longevity is marvelous. You can easily expect it to last for an entire day, and it’s a beast mode cologne so the projection level is much higher than the original Eros.

So if you’re looking for good longevity with a party type of projection, then you can go for Versace Eros or Eros EDP.
On the other hand, if you’re looking for a fresh projection with good longevity, you can go for Eros Flame.

Compliment Factor

Versace Eros, Eros Flame, and Eros EDP are massively popular in the fragrance community. It doesn’t matter what you’re wearing, Eros series will never disappoint you in the case of getting compliments.

Well, Eros Flame gives a citrusy-spicy vibe. There’s nothing to hate in this fragrance. People will love the way you smell, and you’ll get a lot of compliments.

On the other hand, most people know what Versace Eros smells like. And this incredible fragrance will earn you the highest level of compliments.

Also, check out our separate post on  Joop Homme vs Montblanc Individuel

Lastly, Eros EDP is more premium and has a lot more depth than those two. Moreover, the transition of notes and the sensual opening will encourage others to give compliments about how you smell.

So, for compliments, any of these scents will work. But if we compare, Eros EDP is the clear winner here.Eros EDP will simply help you to become the center of the crowd.

Versatility

Eros Flame has fresh and spicy notes. As a result, there is nothing to hate about it, and people will appreciate you a lot. And the sweetness level is so perfect in Eros Flame. The combination of the base of Eros Flame is incredible. You can simply use this fragrance for offices, parties, events, etc.

Even if you’re stuck in a meeting room all day, Eros Flame’s fresh scent will keep you energized.

Eros, Eros EDP, and Eros Flame, all work impressively in winter, fall, and spring. Moreover, they are day-night fragrances.

Though Eros and Eros EDP gathered a lot of success, there are some controversial uses of notes.

Look, the opening of Eros and Eros EDP can be harsh for some people. So in the case of Eros and Eros EDP, I can’t say that everyone will love your fragrance. Moreover, both of them used ambroxan, which seems to be an unpleasant note in the fragrance community.

Eros and Eros EDP both are very loud scents. You can simply use these fragrances at parties, events, dates, etc.

In my opinion, Eros Flame is better for everyday use. And it’s more versatile than Eros and Eros EDP.

Value For Money

In the case of Versace Eros, the price of 100ml is 92$. And it comes in different sizes. And the highest size, which is 200ml, has a price tag of 122$. And the smallest size, which is 50ml, will cost 72$

On the other hand, the price of Versace Eros Flame is pretty similar. The price of 100ml is 102$, and it comes in 50ml too, and the price is 80$.

In the case of Versace Eros EDP, It has only one size on their official website, and it’s 50ml which has a price tag of 80$

Also, check out our separate post on Montblanc Legend vs Explorer vs Spirit

As we can see, the price range of these colognes is pretty similar. And some of them carry the same price tag.

All of these fragrances used rich notes. And the performance level is high for all of them. So you can’t just simply differentiate them, and as they carry the same price tag, so I think it’s better not to consider price here.

As they all carry the same price tag, You can go for any of these if you’re worried about the price range. All of them provide the best value for money.

Overall Scent

Are you looking for an incredible fragrance to wear each and every day? Versace Eros Flame is just the one you’re looking for. It has the potential to become your signature scent.

The notes used in Eros Flame are versatile and inoffensive. And you can use Eros Flame for any events such as business meetings, parties, hangouts, etc.

On the other hand, if you’re a party freak and want to get all the attention, then I’ll suggest you to go for Eros or Eros EDP. The scent profile of Eros and Eros EDP is very sensual. And it’ll help you to maintain a very classy look in every step.

If you’re looking to add a signature party cologne to your collection, Eros or Eros EDP could be the one.

Our Final Verdict

The thing is, all of these fragrances have some pros and cons.

If I had to choose between these two, I would pick Versace Eros EDP over Eros and Eros Flame. The notes of Eros EDP are much more prominent and it has a classic vibe.

The choice is in Your Hands.

As you can see, the performance of Eros EDP is unparalleled, and on the other hand, Eros Flame is more versatile.

But, I can assure you, that all of these fragrances are amazing with well-balanced notes.

If you want to go a different route and maybe consider something different from Versace, check out Le Male vs Ultra Male

Please vote on which cologne you think is better in the pole/comment section. And suggest which fragrance battle you wish to read next, and I’ll get on it.

About The Author
Jhon has a massive collection of 450+ fragrances. He's collecting fragrances since his late 20s. Besides collecting he also has a plan for launching his very own fragrance line.

Leave a Comment