In this match-up, we have two options from Creed, Silver Mountain Water vs Virgin Island Water.
Which of these two best sellers from the Italian designer smells better? If you haven’t tried any one of them yet, then which cologne should you get?
Finding the answer to this can be very frustrating as both of these colognes have many versions and different features.
Don’t worry! After testing both of these colognes on myself, I have rounded out their similarities and differences to help you make an informed decision.
So, without wasting any more time, let’s see which cologne comes out with a victory in this battle.
Clash Of Scents: Silver Mountain Water Vs Virgin Island Water
Silver Mountain Water
Creed Silver Mountain Water was released in 2011 by the famous fashion house Creed.
Undoubtedly, Creed Silver Mountain Water is one of the most incredible fragrances in the market. Creed Silver Mountain Water was developed by Jacques Polge.
Creed Silver Mountain Water is a fresh aquatic cologne. They offer many versions like EDT, EDP, and Parfum. Creed Silver Mountain Water is a crowd-pleasing fragrance, and it’ll recreate your mood in a while.
Virgin Island Water
Main Notes: bergamot, lime, rum, sugar cane, coconut, ylang-ylang, and ginger
Creed Virgin Island Water is considered the king of fragrances. The soothing transition of notes and the compliments factor has made Creed Virgin Island Water a legendary fragrance.
This legendary fragrance was released in 2010, and it was developed by none other than Olivier Creed and Erwin Creed.
As you can see, both of these colognes have the qualities to make you spend a good amount of money on them.
But, these are also two very different scents, with different notes and effects on people.
Read on to find the answers and find the overall best fragrance.
So, here is the comparison between Silver Mountain Water and Virgin Island Water:
Opening
In the case of Creed Silver Mountain Water, they used grapefruit, lemon, mint, and pink pepper. It gives a fresh opening where citrus dominates. The opening is fantastic, and it has balanced sweetness, freshness, and spiciness.
On the other hand, we have the world-famous opening of Creed Virgin Island Water. Never before in the history of perfumes has there been such a mind-blowing opening.
The opening of Creed Virgin Island Water contains pineapple, bergamot, black currant, and apple. Creed Virgin Island Water initially starts with a pineapple burst which makes it stand out from other colognes.
Later on, the opening notes mixes with bergamot, black currant, apple and creates the masterpiece known as Creed Virgin Island Water. The transition of the opening notes is so soothing and luxurious that you’ll fall in love instantly.
Though Creed Silver Mountain Water’s opening is excellent, the opening of Creed Virgin Island Water is the best. You’ll have to praise the opening of Creed Virgin Island Water, and it’s beyond any comparison.
Looking for something different? Then check out Tobacco Oud vs Tuscan Leather
Now, which is better?
Clearly, the winner here is Creed Virgin Island Water. Though it’s a personal preference, it’s really rare to find an opening like Creed Virgin Island Water. In my opinion, Among these two, Creed Virgin Island Water has the best opening.
Projection And Longevity
Both Creed Silver Mountain Water and Creed Virgin Island Water projects really strongly after you wear them. As they both used premium notes, you can be sure about getting excellent projection and longevity from these colognes.
The longevity of Creed Silver Mountain Water and Creed Virgin Island Water is almost the same. I got similar types of longevity from both of these fragrances.
In the case of Creed Silver Mountain Water, it starts with a robust fresh projection, and after some time, it tempers down and lasts an entire day. It’ll undoubtedly help you to refresh your mood. The freshness of this fragrance is delightful.
If we talk about Creed Virgin Island Water, I must say the opening projection of Creed Virgin Island Water is the best. After a vast projection, it calms down gradually and stays on your skin for a day. The scent is really enjoyable, and people can’t resist them complimenting you if you’re wearing Creed Virgin Island Water.
As we can see, both of these colognes perform fantastically. Both of them will make you stand out in a crowd, and they will encourage people to get into you. Both of them require 5-7 sprays for a day.
So, if you’re looking for good longevity with a fresh projection, then you can go for Creed Silver Mountain Water. On the other hand, if you’re looking for an elite projection with good longevity, you can go for Creed Virgin Island Water.
Compliment Factor
Creed Silver Mountain Water and Creed Virgin Island Water both are massively popular fragrances in the world. But here, we’ll figure out which one gets more compliments.
Well, Creed Silver Mountain Water gives a citrusy aquatic vibe. There’s nothing to hate in this fragrance. People will love the way you smell, and you’ll get a lot of compliments.
On the other hand, most people know what Creed Virgin Island Water smells like. And this incredible fragrance will earn you the highest level of compliments.
Also, you can check out Le Male vs Ultra Male
Firstly, Creed Virgin Island Water has a premium and rich scent. Moreover, the transition of notes and the sensual opening will encourage others to give compliments about how good you smell.
Creed Virgin Island Water will simply help you to stand out in the crowd. It’ll make you the king of any event that you’re attending.
So, for compliments, any of these two scents will work. But if we compare, Creed Virgin Island Water is the clear winner here.
Versatility
Creed Silver Mountain Water used fresh and aquatic notes. As a result, there is nothing to hate about it and people will appreciate you a lot. You can simply use this fragrance for offices, parties, events, etc.
Even if you’re stuck in a meeting room, Creed Silver Mountain Water’s fresh scent will enhance your energy a lot.
Well, between these two SMW works better in summer and you can wear this fragrance any season. Creed Virgin Island Water works better in summer and spring. You can also wear this in the fall.
Though Creed Virgin Island Water gathered a lot of success, there are some controversial uses of notes. Moreover, the opening of Creed Virgin Island Water can be harsh for someone.
In my opinion, Creed Silver Mountain Water is better for everyday use. And it’s more versatile than Creed Virgin Island Water.
Value For Money
In the case of Creed Silver Mountain Water, the price of 100ml is 100$. And it comes in three different sizes. And the highest size, which is 150ml, has a price tag of 135$.
On the other hand, the price of Creed Virgin Island Water is pretty high. The price of 100ml is 445$, and it comes in five different sizes. The highest price of Creed Virgin Island Water is 1695$ which is for a 1000ml bottle.
So as we can see, there is a massive gap between the prices of these two colognes.
Also, you can check out Versace Pour Homme vs Versace Dylan Blue
Both of these fragrances used rich notes. As Creed is now considered as a heritage of fragrance, that’s why the brand value of Creed is so high.
So, I can say both of them deserve the price tag they have on their body, but I’ll go for Creed Silver Mountain Water for the best value.
Overall Scent
Are you looking for an incredible fragrance to wear each and every day?
Creed Silver Mountain Water is just the one you’re looking for. It has the potential to become your signature scent.
The notes used in Creed Silver Mountain Water are versatile and inoffensive.
Also, you can use Creed Silver Mountain Water for any events such as business meetings, parties, hangouts, etc. And it’s so popular that people will know what you are wearing instantly.
On the other hand, Creed Virgin Island Water is a masterpiece. If you don’t own a multi industries business, I’ll suggest not choosing this as a signature scent. It’s better to use it for special events. And if your wallet lets you choose Creed Virgin Island Water as a signature scent, that’d be awesome.
If you’re looking to add a signature showstopper cologne to your collection, Creed Virgin Island Water could be the one.
Our Final Verdict
Both fragrances have some pros and cons.
If I had to choose between these two, I would pick Creed Virgin Island Water over Creed Silver Mountain Water. It is one of the most superior cologne I’ve ever sniffed, and every bit of it feels premium.
The choice is in Your Hands.
Both of these fragrances will enrich your fragrance collection. And people will appreciate you for your choice.
If you want to go a different route and maybe consider something different from Chanel or Creed, you could also check ultimate comparison of Wanted by Night vs Dior Sauvage
Please vote on which cologne you think is better in the pole/comment section. And suggest which fragrance battle you wish to read next, and I’ll get on it.
