5 Amazing Dupes That Smell Similar to Old Spice [In 2024]

Written By John Carter

Shulton Company Old spice is the most classic fragrance you will ever come across. Old Spice is an old but gold cologne.

If you think you have not smelled it, you are wrong. The moment you take a sniff of Old Spice, it is going to remind you of your grandfather. It was a big hit in the 21st century.

And, if you are here because you love the scent of Old Spice but want the scent in a modern way, you are in the right place.

I will be mentioning all the great colognes which smell alike Old spice. Keep reading till the end.

Which Colognes Are Similar To Old Spice?

Shulton Company released Old Spice in 1938 by Albert Hauck.

The top notes of Old Spice are Nutmeg, Star Anise, Aldehydes, Orange and Lemon.

In today’s world, Old Spice is not a relevant fragrance anymore. However, as the smell is so nice, some people still look for it.

Old Spice is an oriented spicy fragrance. The fruity and crispy starting takes a deep turn with amber and spicy notes.

Before florals like jasmine and carnation take over, the citrus fades away. The floral notes stay for a while and then get a spicy touch from the cinnamon.

The cinnamon takes over the whole dry down with the help of cedar and almond. Vanilla adds to the fragrance at the end and gives a gourmand feel.

Follow our guide: Colognes That Smell Similar To Davidoff Cool Water

Old Spice has 4 to 5 hours of longevity with a moderate projection. The versatility of Old Spice is amazing. It is an all-year-round scent, and you can wear it on any occasion.

So, here are the best colognes that smell like Old Spice:

Creed Viking

Top notes are Pink Pepper, Spicy Mint, Bergamot, Lemon, Absinthe and Orange;

Middle notes are Lavender, Bulgarian Rose, Clove, Allspice, Jasmine and Orris Root;

Base notes are Vetiver, Cedar, White Musk and Tonka Bean.

Viking was released in 2017 by one of the world’s most-known niche perfume houses.

The opening of Viking is similar to Old Spice. It starts with a blast of citruses with spice from pepper and spicy mint. It is quite mature and appealing.

After a while, the citrus is replaced with lavender, which gives the fragrance a floral touch in the middle. The spicy touch is always present in the scent.

Sandalwood comes at the end and makes the fragrance more muscular than ever. The peppery accord tones down in the dry down, but it is still there. And it is considered to be the most beautiful part of the cologne.

Viking is a perfectly clean, fresh, and spicy fragrance with moderate projection power and longevity of 7 to 8 hours.

When to wear?

The versatility of Viking is amazing. You can wear it all year long, day and night, on any occasion; Viking is always useful.

Why should you wear it?

[/ts_list]
  • Versatile fragrance.
  • Quite similar to Old Spice. [/ts_list]

Paul Sebastian PS Fine Cologne

Top notes are Lavender, Sage and Nutmeg;

Middle notes are Ylang-Ylang, Rose, Jasmine, Cloves and Spices;

Base notes are Musk, Amber, Oakmoss and Patchouli.

Another old-school fragrance like Old Spice is PS Fine Cologne. It is super cheap. But with this low price tag, PS Fine Cologne performs like a beast. With only 2 sprays, it fills the room the moment you enter it.

The lasting power is also top-notch. You will easily get a longevity of 12 hours minimum.

Most old fragrances have in common that they are more aromatic than sweet. PS Fine Cologne is no different.

This fragrance starts with lavender rather than being citrusy. And it becomes spicier with time. Musk is a big part of PS Fine Cologne, making it classy and muscular.

PS Fine Cologne might change your mind even if you dislike classic and old fragrances.

Read more on: Recommended Clones of Acqua di Gio Absolu

When to wear?

Fall, winter and spring are perfect for PS Fine Cologne. As it is a heavy scent, you should ignore it in the summer. Clubbing and dating are great occasions to wear it.

Why should you wear it?

[/ts_list]
  • Mass appealing.
  • Great projection and longevity.
  • Great value for its money. [/ts_list]

Pierre Cardin Pour Monsieur

Top notes are Lavender, Orange, Basil, Lemon and Bergamot;

Middle notes are Sandalwood, Leather, Carnation, Patchouli and Geranium;

Base notes are Leather, Oakmoss, Benzoin, Vanilla, Amber and Tonka Bean.

It is hard to find fragrances that smell like old ones because perfumers do not make new perfumes similar to them.

So, we have another oldie on our list, Pierre Cardin Pour Monsieur, released in 1972. The bottle is unique, and it looks like a water tank.

When you sniff Pierre Cardin Pour, Monsieur, you will know it is an old fragrance. It is not bad, but the composition of perfumes nowadays is very different from the past.

Pierre Cardin Pour Monsieur is a natural cologne. It opens up with citrus-like Old Spice but less. And also, the citrusy notes are mixed with carnation. This classy fragrance also contains some spicy accords.

It is a complex perfume, and many notes work behind the cologne, making it mature and vintage.

However, Pierre Cardin Pour Monsieur’s projection and longevity are not great. It will give a longevity of only 2 to 3 hours.

When to wear?

Pierre Cardin Pour Monsieur is for winter and fall, and you can also wear it in springtime.

Why should you wear it?

[/ts_list]
  • Classic old-school fragrance.
  • Muscular cologne.
  • Affordable. [/ts_list]

Maurer & Wirtz Tabac

Top notes are Aldehydes, Lavender, Neroli, Lemon and Bergamot;

Middle notes are Carnation, Sandalwood, Pine Tree Needles, Rose, Jasmine and Orris Root;

Base notes are Tobacco, Musk, Oakmoss, Amber, Tonka Bean and Vanilla.

A German perfume house, Maurer & Wirtz, released Tabac in 1959.

The fragrance has a strong presence of aldehydes which means you will feel like you are under the sun shining on a clear sky. It also has a lot of citruses like Old Spice.

In the middle, carnation creates the floral touch of the fragrance. Pine tree needles are a quite interesting addition to the cologne.

Tabac also has spicy accords, but they are not as strong as in Old Spice. Tabac comes with more sweet and floral aspects.

But the most dominating note is tobacco which also gives the cologne its uniqueness from Old Spice.

This cologne is not built to provide you with good lasting power. It can serve you for 3 to 4 hours maximum. However, the price of Tabac makes it worth it. It makes a strong statement.

Also, check out: Colognes That Smell Similar to Polo Blue

When to wear?

As Tabac got some fresh notes, you can wear it all year round.

Why should you wear it?

[/ts_list]
  • Blast from the past cologne.
  • Muscular fragrance.
  • Smells expensive. [/ts_list]

Jovan Sex Appeal

Notes: Spices, Green notes.

This child of 1975 starts with a very spicy kick from the mixture of cinnamon and cloves. This makes the fragrance very herbal and green. A little touch of citrus will remind you of Old Spice.

As there are only two groups of notes present, spices and green notes, it is a straightforward cologne.

The dry down of this cologne is very subtle and close to your skin.

The longevity of Sex Appeal is not much, 1 to 2 hours only; however, the price is quite cheap so that you can reapply without thinking.

If you want to seduce women, this old fragrance does more than the job. It was created to attract women.

So, the cologne is not for youngsters. It is made for mature men. And it will also remind you of old times, mostly because it smells like your father or grandfather.

When to wear?

It is a winter or fall cologne. The spices will work blissfully on cold days.

Why should you wear it?

[/ts_list]
  • Spicer than Old Spice.
  • Very appealing cologne. [/ts_list]

Conclusion

Old Spice is an old classic fragrance still admired by many and has some great alternatives if you are into old smell scents. Try the mentioned colognes in this list, and you won’t be disappointed.

If you have any further queries, please feel free to ask them in the comment section, and I would be happy to answer them.

About The Author
Jhon has a massive collection of 450+ fragrances. He's collecting fragrances since his late 20s. Besides collecting he also has a plan for launching his very own fragrance line.

Leave a Comment