Top 6 Colognes Similar To Black Phantom Kilian [2024]

I came across Black Phantom by Kilian while looking for a warm, sweet, yet masculine composition for my partner. As soon as I sprayed the scent, its luxurious and well-balanced quality won my heart.

However, this splendid scent for the cold season may be too costly for some people.

Hence, I researched and sorted some affordable Black Phantom smell-alikes.

All of them are worth a shot, so stay tuned to find out more about them.

What Does Black Phantom Kilian Smell Like?

Black Phantom by Kilian smells delicious with notes like chocolate, roasted nuts, and coffee. From the start, you’ll feel the rich papery vanilla tone, further enriched by bitter almonds and a hint of heliotrope. It then settles with a sweet, buttery sandalwood base.

And the best thing about this cologne is its 8 hours of longevity with enormous sillage.

Now, let’s take a look at Black Phantom’s note formulation:

Top Note: Rum

Middle Notes: Dark Chocolate, Coffee, Almond, Heliotrope

Base Notes: Caramel, Sugar Cane, Sandalwood, Vetiver

From the first sniff, Black Phantom smells sultry, sweet, and boozy, but in a clean way. It somewhat reminds me of a super luxurious coffee bar.

The core brings in a warm gourmand and creamy feel with a deep blend of coffee, chocolate, and almond. It’s sweet and deep but never gets cloying due to the presence of fresh, floral heliotrope.

Finally comes the dry-down along with a refined intoxicating sensation of sandalwood and vetiver. Though you’re supposed to pick them up at this stage, I didn’t smell any caramel or sugar cane throughout the base.

Overall, this can be an attractive option to rock the winter nights. But this one’s pretty overpriced. And if you need something affordable with a similar gourmand vibe, check out the dupes given in the next part.

What Colognes Smell Similar To Black Phantom Kilian?

Black Phantom is a mind-blowing composition and there’s no doubt about it. Seeing its massive popularity, many other brands launched colognes with similar notes and scent profiles.

To ease your work, among all these Black Phantom smell-alikes, I found the ones that are budget-friendly and good in quality.

Here are the ideal alternatives for Black Phantom by Kilian:

1. Dark Knight Alexandria Fragrances

Being on the market for a while, Black Phantom has its fair share of clones and replicas. Among them, Dark Knight by Alexandria Fragrances is the only one that perfectly mimics the cozy, ambery Black Phantom tone.

This cologne offers around 85% similarity to the OG. It opens a little bit differently. Whereas in the Killian one, rum comes out strongly in the opening, Dark Knight has a subtle and less sweet beginning.

As time went by, I could smell the bitter-sweet sensation of coffee, chocolate, and almond mix. But here all the notes were stronger, hence, the core might smell a little bit more bitter than what you get from the OG.

When the aroma settles down, the sweet, woody accords become more apparent. With a caramelized, creamy, sandalwood aroma, its dry-down smells so similar that I can hardly distinguish it from Black Phantom.

Also, this Kilian Black Phantom dupe outperforms the OG by presenting over 10 hours of longevity. The projection of this perfume is commendable as well.

When To Wear

Any evening date or casual night occasion throughout the cold season is the best time to wear Dark Knight. You can also wear it at any day-time event, but remember to spray lightly if you don’t wanna smell cloying.

Why Should You Buy

2. Coffee & Whiskey Bath & Body Works

If you’re looking for a simple and affordable Black Phantom Kilian dupe for daily use, go for Coffee & Whiskey by Bath & Body Works. Introduced in 2022, this cologne has only two notes, coffee and whiskey. But the warm, sweet, smooth ambiance it creates is irresistible.

It opens with a boozy, sweet, and silky vibe of whiskey, very similar to what you get on the first whiff of Black Phantom.

As the aroma develops, it becomes chocolatey sweet, gourmand, and creamy. Coffee appears after a while, adding more energetic and pleasant qualities to the sweet core.

It smoothes out more in the dry-down, where I could finally smell the sweet, creamy coffee aroma to the fullest. At this stage, it gives me the feel of sitting in a comforting coffee shop while it’s snowing outside.

Though it doesn’t have any woody accords, the cologne still gives a seductive masculine vibe.

Also, you’ll still get a solid 6 hours of longevity and gentle sillage from this affordable fragrance.

When To Wear

This cologne comes with a refined coziness that can make your coffee dates on a winter or fall evening more engaging. Other than dates, this fragrance works nicely as a signature scent.

Why Should You Buy

3. Cognac Cafe Galleria Parfums

Cognac Cafe by Galleria Parfums is my next affordable option for you. This cologne strongly reminds me of Kilian Black Phantom, but it’s stronger, with more coffee and ambery accords.

It starts off brilliantly with a smooth, creamy, sweet coffee aroma that will instantly wake up all your senses. The opening is very strong with coffee and also has a subtle nutty, woody undertone.

Gradually, the cologne becomes smoother, sweeter, and a lot boozier with cognac and sandalwood in the heart. Meanwhile, papyrus adds an unusual cooling, green character to the scent.

As soon as it reaches the dry-down, you’ll feel a warm, dense, and classy woody-vanilla base along with amber-like facets of myrrh.

Overall, this is a gorgeous option for sweet, boozy, yet mysterious scent lovers. Also, this fragrance is very strong. Only a couple of sprays are enough to get an elegant and addictive aura for the next 12 hours.

Plus, you’ll get better sillage and projection from this Black Phantom substitute.

When To Wear

Cognac Cafe by Galleria Parfums will be too strong and warm for hot weather. So, to get the best experience, wear this lovely fragrance on any kind of occasion during the winter or autumn.

Why Should You Buy

4. La Rhapsodie Noire Parfums Dusita

In my opinion, La Rhapsodie Noire is a more charming and wearable alternative to Black Phantom. And Parfums Dusita launched this mind-seizing gourmand fougere scent in 2022.

The opening of this cologne merges the clean, refined freshness of lavender and sage with other divine floral accords. This fresh floral tone fades quickly, and the aroma turns gourmand with coffee and tobacco in the core.

I could also smell the rum in the background, balancing the bitterness of coffee by adding its sweet, boozy character.

My favorite part is the dry-down. It’s deep, comforting, and also carries the irresistible charm of vanilla and tonka bean. With an earthy woody hint of vetiver and sandalwood, the cologne leaves behind a seductive scent trail.

Besides, this unique fragrance will provide you with 10 hours of longevity.

When To Wear

You can wear La Rhapsodie Noire both day and night throughout the fall and winter. Its luxurious and well-balanced tone fits perfectly both formal and casual scenarios. Yet, I find it more suitable as a signature fragrance.

Why Should You Buy

5. Insomnia Faviol Seferi

Smoother, sweeter, and muskier, but Insomnia by Faviol Seferi will still give you a 90% similar vibe to Kilian Black Phantom.

Honestly, I prefer this cologne over the Killian one, because of its stronger and smoother boozy traits.

Insomnia opens with a similarly sweet, warm, and delicious chocolate and rum mix. Soon, you’ll feel the exciting coffee nuance balancing the intense sweetness, while adding more intriguing facets to the scent.

The fragrance ultimately settles with the sophisticated, spicy, nutty sensation of vanilla and sandalwood.

You may find this dry-down almost identical to Black Phantom, but it excels with an exotic patchouli hint that also gives an exciting quality to the base.

Furthermore, Faviol Seferi Insomnia is less expensive, yet it will give you better longevity and sillage.

When To Wear

This nice and cozy fragrance will be the best option for your evening and nighttime outings in colder months. I find its aroma perfect for friendly gatherings, clubbing, holiday dinners, and sometimes simply for a coffee date.

Why Should You Buy

6. Chi Tiziana Terenzi

If you like your winter frags with an intense earthy, woody sensation, Chi by Tiziana Terenzi would be a perfect Black Phantom replacement for you.

Well, this cologne was my colleague’s signature winter aroma. And as soon as I caught a whiff of it, I could feel its resemblance to Black Phantom.

Though I didn’t get any caramel sweetness in Black Phantom, Tiziana Terenzi Chi exerts a nutty, sweet, caramel-like coffee aroma from the beginning.

As it develops, you’ll start to feel its true gourmand nature. The combination of oud, vanilla, and earthy notes smells divine and extremely intoxicating.

Slowly, the rich creaminess of vanilla enriches further with nutty tonka bean and oud in the base. The aroma finally closes, leaving behind a seductive, masculine, and very elegant scent trail.

Furthermore, Ursa is my other favorite gourmand scent from this niche house. And if you like to wear expensive-smelling winter frags, I will recommend trying Tiziana Terenzi Ursa and other colognes similar to it.

When To Wear

From romantic winter dates to cozy fall evenings, you can wear Chi Tiziana Terenzi anywhere you want. I find it best suited for classy parties, clubbing, or blind dates throughout the winter. It will make you smell both luxurious and sensual with only a few sprays.

Why Should You Buy

Final Words

Kilian Black Phantom captivates everyone with its warm, alluring charm. And the dupes that I’ve listed here have a similar appeal but also have some originality of their own.

Plus, you can get most of these replacements for Black Phantom at a much lower price without compromising on quality or performance.

So, check them out and just pick the one that fits your mood and occasion.