Once you enter the territory of Creed, there is no going back. And who wants to go back from masterpieces like Creed Green Irish Tweed and Silver Mountain Water?
These summer fragrances have marked their region with their splendid mix of notes. Therefore, selecting one among these two stunning vintage scents can take more work than you think.
Don’t worry. I am here to your rescue. Through this context, I will tell you every aspect of Creed GIT & Creed SMW briefly.
So, for a quick round-up, stay put till the end.
Clash Of Scents: Creed Green Irish Tweed Vs Silver Mountain Water
Creed Green Irish Tweed
Main Notes: Lemon Verbena, Iris, Violet Leaf, Ambergris, Sandalwood
Green Irish Tweed is a combined creation of Olivier Creed and Pierre Bourdon. This legendary woody floral musk cologne was launched way back in 1985.
Being one of the signature scents of the House of Creed, this fresh and clean fragrance makes a good impact on others in a positive way. And it’s also popular among celebrities.
This exquisite masculine cologne opens with a blast of floral freshness and dries down to a soft, milky, musky tone.
In a word, it’s the best combination of air, land, and sea.
Moreover, GIT has high-quality natural ingredients that blend harmoniously but have a hefty price tag. Also, its 12 hours of longevity is impressive, even with moderate sillage.
If you are on a budget, try out Creed Green Irish Tweed clones instead.
Silver Mountain Water
Main Notes: Bergamot, Mandarin Orange, Green Tea, Black Currant, Musk, Petitgrain, Sandalwood, Galbanum
Silver Mountain Water is one of the most iconic Creed fragrances. This heavenly scent was launched in 1995, and ever since, its alluring aura has been enchanting fresh perfume lovers.
And the best part is that it’s unisex, so you and your loved ones can use it together. A convenient way to utilize expensive fragrance!
Moreover, SMW has all the elements of charm. The citrusy, juicy fruits create a bright and vibrant aura, which slowly turns into a sweet, mature layer of air that will linger around you for 6 hours.
Though it leaves a moderate trail, it’s still a timeless gold in a simple white bottle.
This niche brand is worth every penny if you plan to buy among the best smelling Creed perfumes.
Enough with the introductory. Now it’s time I give you a full tour of every nook and cranny of Creed Green Irish and Creed Silver Mountain Water.
So, here is my thorough comparison between Creed Silver Mountain Water and Creed Green Irish:
Opening
The top of any fragrance plays a crucial role when you are buying it. It’s the first smell that touches your nose, and if it reaches your heart, then it’s a must-buy.
The opening of Green Irish Tweed is green and natural. Just after the first sniff, it will take you closer to a secret forest where the purity of the tree branches sparkles through the rays of sunlight.
Here, you will sense the fresh herbal floral smell of lemon verbena, along with the powdery, earthy aura of Iris flowers.
On the other hand, the Initial blast of Silver Mountain Water is green, aquatic, and citrusy. It will give you the vibe of an orange garden where new produce is growing, and the grown fruits are ready to harvest.
Being very bright and light, it also has a sharp tone, which is a plus point.
So, from the discussion, it’s clear that both GIT and SMW come with the best top notes and are equally energizing.
In my opinion, it’s a tie between Green Irish Tweed and Silver Mountain Water regarding opening.
Projection And Longevity
Now, I will discuss how long these airy gems last on your skin and clothes, along with their projection.
The first one is Green Irish Tweed. This nature-embellished cologne comes with 12 hours of longevity. So, with a few pumps, you are set for the day.
So, go for walks or casual outings, your fragrance will boost your mood whether it’s summer or spring. And in terms of projection, it’s not beasty, rather intimate to moderate.
Conversely, Creed Silver Mountain Water lasts for 6 to 8 hours. So, it’s a safe, moderate scent. And if you are out for a longer time, consider taking it with you for further reapplication.
Also, its projection is moderate. That means only those who are around your arm’s length can smell your mild aroma.
Now, it’s clear that Creed Green Irish Tweed has the upper hand when it comes to longevity and projection.
Complement Factor
Complement Factor is another indicator to see if a fragrance is worth buying.
Creed Silver Mountain Water is like a flow of waterfall that has washed away the citrusy fruits, sweet, alluring flowers, and blocks of fragrant wood along with it.
From the tangy and bright top to the woody, soft, intense dry-down, Silver Mountain Water smells amazing and soothing. And as time passes, it sets on your skin to enchant you and others around you.
Though it projects to a limited range still, people will ask you what you are wearing no matter what. So, you will get compliments for sure.
Meanwhile, Green Irish Tweed is a woody floral musk fragrance that lasts for 10+ hours, and with its wonderful, floral, woody, and powdery notes, it’s praisable during the warmer days.
And as the base shows up, the rich, sweet, woody, and passionate vibe will turn heads.
So, which one is the better complement achiever?
Green Irish Tweed is the winner here because it is more dense and long-lasting.
Versatility
Who doesn’t want a versatile scent when they are spending a fortune on a niche fragrance? If you ask me, it has to be adaptable.
Creed SMW is quite versatile. The first thing is that it is a unisex perfume, so both men and women can pull it off. During summer and spring, its stimulating fruity, floral, and herbal aura will brighten your days.
Moreover, you can use this fragrance to some extent in fall and cold winter.
On the contrary, you can wear Green Irish Tweed in summer, spring, and fall daytime without any problem. During the winter night, it also works fine because of the woody, earthy tone of sandalwood and ambergris.
As this masculine scent lasts up to 12 long hours, you are tension-free with one application.
So, in conclusion, both are equally versatile and charming to serve you in every weather.
Value For Money
The main reason why Creed perfumes are so expensive is their high-quality ingredients. And for SMW and GIT, the reason is also the same.
Creed Green Irish Tweed comes in five available sizes. The price of a 50 ml bottle is $345, a 100 bottle is $470, a 250 ml bottle is $755, and a 500 ml bottle of this gentleman’s cologne costs $1205.
Where Silver Mountain Water also has five sizes. 50 ml is $345, 100 ml is $470, 250 ml is $755, 500 ml is $1205 and 1000 ml is $1685.
My friend got the 100 ml flacon and is obsessed with this well-balanced aroma.
So, price-wise, both SMW and GIT are on the same level. Here, it’s about your preference, which one suits you, not the cost.
Overall Scent
Finally, it’s time for the overall scent profile comparison.
Creed Silver Mountain Water smells fresh and delightful from the very beginning. It opens with a blend of citrusy bergamot and sweet, juicy Mandarin orange, which mixes with herbal green tea nuance to create an everlasting effect.
You will also feel the rich and sensual presence of black currant vividly.
Then, slowly, the softness of sandalwood will create a balanced layer at the base, along with the intensity of galbanum and musk, together with a more green tone.
Inversely, Creed Green Irish Tweed has an herbal, clean, and floral top consisting of lemon verbena and iris.
The middle of this classic scent is fresher because of the violet leaf. And the woody sweetness of sandalwood and the animalic aura of ambergris make the dry-down delightful.
Now the question is, which one is better?
Considering other differentiating factors, the winner for me is Silver Mountain Water, as I prefer the flow of refreshing aura until the end.
Anyway, if you want to smell amazing all around the year and impress your partner, try the best Creed colognes for men.
Final Verdict
Creed Green Irish Tweed and Silver Mountain Water are unique and have their own specific quality that makes them so popular till now.
SMW is versatile, soothing, and fresh with a tangy, fruity essence that projects moderately. So, if you are looking for a regular-use perfume, it’s the ideal pick.
Moreover, GIT is long-lasting, earthy, and sweet, with a touch of intensity that will attract others. Therefore, to enjoy a mass-appealing scent that will serve you all day, there is no better option than Green Irish Tweed.
And both of these have the exact price point.
So, you can choose the fragrance depending on your preference or buy both of them if money is not an issue for you. Either way, it’s a win.
