Versace Eau Fraiche vs Versace Man EDT [Comparison 2024]

In this match-up, we have two options from Versace, Eau Fraiche, and Versace Man EDT.

Which of these two best sellers from the Italian designer smells better?  If you haven’t tried any one of them yet, then which cologne should you get?

Finding the answer to this can be very frustrating as both of these colognes have many versions and different features.

Don’t worry! After testing both of these colognes on myself, I have rounded out their similarities and differences to help you make an informed decision.

So, without wasting any more time, let’s see which cologne comes out with a victory in this battle.

Clash of Scents: Eau Fraiche vs Versace Man

Versace Eau Fraiche

Main Notes: Lemon, Rosewood, Carambola, Cedar leaves, Tarragon, Sage, Musk, Amber, Sycamore.

Versace Eau Fraiche was released in 2006 by the famous Italian fashion house Versace. Undoubtedly, Versace Eau Fraiche is one of the most incredible fragrances on the market. Versace Eau Fraiche was developed byOlivier Cresp.

Versace Eau Fraiche is a woody aquatic fragrance. It’s a fresh fragrance, and the aroma is incredible. It’ll help you to recreate your mood and feel something special.

Versace Man

Main Notes: Bergamot, Neroli, Black pepper, Cardamom, Saffron, Amber, Cashmere wood, Labdanum, Tobacco

Versace Man is a spicy fragrance. It was released in 2003. And the nose behind this fragrance is Domitille Michalon Bertier. It’s a fantastic fragrance and a huge compliments getter.

Now, how to know which cologne has better performance, and which will better value your money? Read on to find the answers and find the superior fragrance.

So, here is the comparison between Versace Eau Fraiche and Versace Man EDT:

Opening

In the case of Versace Eau Fraiche, they used bergamot, lemon, star fruit, cardamom, and rosewood. In a word, the opening is delicious. It has everything to fall in love with.

The citrus level is balanced, and the use of star fruit is groundbreaking. Cardamom adds a sufficient amount of spiciness, and rosewood adds depth to it.

On the other hand, Versace Man used pepper, angelica, neroli, and bergamot in the opening. The white floral touch is incredible, and pepper took the opening to a different level. And the initial burst of bergamot is mind-blowing.

As you can see, both of these fragrances have a good opening. It’s really tough to choose one among these. But the opening of Versace Eau Fraiche is something else. It’s really hard to find an opening like this.

And the star fruit is really a star here. In the summertime, this fragrance performs like a guardian angel.

Looking for something different? Then check out Spicebomb Extreme vs Wanted by Night

Now, which is better?

Clearly, the winner here is Versace Eau Fraiche. In my opinion, Among these two, Versace Eau Fraiche has the best opening.

Projection and Longevity

Versace Eau Fraiche and Versace Man used different methods of projection and longevity. Both of these fragrances have enough reasons to do that. Let me brief you clearly.

In the case of Versace Eau Fraiche, it’s a summer cologne, and it performs like a summer cologne. The longevity and the projection level are moderate.

This fresh scent starts with a citrus blast, and later on, it stays like half of the day. The projection level is moderate and fresh.

If we talk about Versace Man, it’s a winter cologne, and the performance is top-notch. It easily stays like a day, and the projection level is much high. It starts with a floral-spicy scent, and after some time, it blooms properly and stays like a whole day.

As you can see, for the difference in weather, these fragrances work differently. And they are perfect in their own field.

So, if you’re looking for a summer cologne with good longevity and fresh projection, then you can go for Versace Eau Fraiche.

On the other hand, if you’re looking for a winter cologne with good longevity and projection, you can go for Versace Man.

Compliment Factor

Versace Eau Fraiche and Versace Man both are massively popular fragrances in the world. But here, we’ll figure out which gets more compliments.

Well, Versace Eau Fraiche gives a citrusy aquatic vibe. There’s nothing to hate in this fragrance. And it’s moderate projection will help you to get compliments from others.

On the other hand, Versace Man is really good at the projection and this spicy fragrance is enough to amaze others. The usage of tobacco and amber makes this fragrance top-notch, and people will love your choice.

Also, check out our separate post on Dior Sauvage vs Versace Eros Comparison

As we can see, both of these fragrances will help you to gather compliments but in different situations. For more compliments, it’s better to use Versace Man.

So, for compliments, any of these two scents will work. But if we compare, Versace Man is the clear winner here.

Versatility

In the case of Versace Man, the projection level is moderately high than Versace Eau Fraiche, and people will love your fragrance. But it’s a spicy fragrance, and the level of spices is much higher than Eau Fraiche.

Moreover, some people can’t take spicy aromas. And they used tobacco which also can be offensive.

On the other hand, Versace Eau Fraiche works like a guardian angel in the summer. It’s inoffensive and versatile. So if you want to smell fresh and don’t want to bother people with your scent, then it’s better to use Versace Eau Fraiche.

You can use this fragrance anytime and anywhere, such as offices, business meetings, hangouts, e.t.c.

So, both of these fragrances are versatile. But if we compare, Versace Eau Fraiche is more versatile.

Value For Money

In the case of Versace Eau Fraiche, it comes in three different sizes (50ml, 100ml, 200ml). The price of 50ml is 70$, and the price of 200ml is 120$

On the other hand, Versace Man is discontinued, and it’s really rare to find this cologne. Some retailers sells this cologne at 80$-200$

So as we can see, Versace Man is discontinued, and it’s really tough to get this fragrance.

Here’s our ultimate comparison of Acqua di Gio Profumo vs Profondo 

Versace Eau Fraiche carries a fair price tag, and I’m sure you’ll thank me after you buy this fragrance at 70$.

As the price of Versace Man is not stable, so the winner is Versace Eau Fraiche.

Overall Scent

Are you looking for an incredible fragrance to wear each and every day? Versace Eau Fraiche is just the one you’re looking for. It has the potential to become your signature scent.

The notes used in Versace Eau Fraiche are versatile and inoffensive. And you can use Versace Eau Fraiche for any events such as business meetings, parties, hangouts, etc. And it’s so popular that people will know what you are wearing instantly.

On the other hand, Versace Pour Homme is a masterpiece. But this fragrance is discontinued, and it’s really hard to get this cologne. And I don’t think you will find another bottle of Versace Man after you finish one.

If you’re looking to add a signature versatile cologne to wear every day, Versace Eau Fraiche could be the one.

Our Final Verdict

As you can see, Versace Man’s performance is higher here. On the other hand, you can’t just simply deny the inoffensiveness of Versace Eau Fraiche.

Versace Man has a huge compliments factor, but this cologne is already discontinued.

If I had to choose between these two, I would pick Versace Eau Fraiche over Versace Man. It is one of the most superior cologne I’ve ever sniffed, and every bit of it feels premium. Moreover, Versace Man is already discontinued.

If you want to go a different route and maybe consider something different from Versace, you could also check out our separate post on  Joop Homme vs Montblanc Individuel

Please vote on which cologne you think is better in the pole/comment section. And suggest which fragrance battle you wish to read next, and I’ll get on it.