YSL Y comes with such an appealing fragrance that it managed to sustain a massive fan base even after years of its first launch.
But the thing is, YSL Y is available in both EDP and EDT versions. As both seem to have similar composition and tone, it may lead you to confusion while purchasing.
Hence, in this article, I’m gonna compare these two versions of YSL Y to find out which one offers better scent and performance.
So, if you don’t know which one to get between these two incredible YSL Y iterations, stay till the end.
Clash Of Scents: YSL Y EDT Vs EDP
YSL Y EDT
Main Notes: Aldehydes, Bergamot, Pineapple Ginger, Mint, Apple, Violet Leaf, Sage, Geranium, Ambergris, Musk, Cedar, Balsam Fir, and Incense
Designed by Dominique Ropion, YSL Y EDT was launched in 2017 by Yves Saint Laurent. With a fresh woody aromatic scent, YSL Y became one of the most coveted colognes from the brand.
It comes with such a unique composition of green, floral, and musky accords that only Dominique Ropion can think of. He did this job of making a youthful Cologne very perfectly, and YSL Y came out as a crowd-pleasing scent.
YSL Y EDP
Main Notes: Apple, Ginger, Bergamot, Sage, Juniper Berries, Geranium, Amberwood, Tonka Bean, Cedar, Olibanum, and Vetiver
Well, after the massive popularity of the EDT version, YSL decided to launch YSL Y EDP in 2018. This version is also a creation of Dominique Ropion.
But the main difference between the YSL Y EDT and EDP is the concentration they come with. Other than higher concentration, YSL EDP smells a bit sweeter as well, mainly because of a few changes in the composition.
However, just like the original, YSL Y EDP also smells alluring, which is why it became one of the best colognes of this line.
Then which one between these two incredible YSL cologne should you go for?
Stay till the end if you wanna find that out!
Well, sometimes, this fragrance is also compared to other designer best-selling colognes like Versace Eros. So, to know if it’s really better than this party beast, read our article on YSL Y EDP vs Versace Eros.
Now, let’s move to comparing the EDP and EDT edition of YSL Y!
And here is a detailed comparison between YSL Y EDT and YSL Y EDP to find the better one:
Opening
Many people buy colognes only after falling in love with the opening scent. So comparing how both YSL Y do in their opening act is a must.
So, let’s jump to it, then!
The alluring aldehyde and bergamot combo gives YSL Y EDT a light, fresh, and lively start. The opening gets more interesting when the spicy fizzy ginger adds up.
Citrusy bergamot dominates the opening giving a zesty character to it. But when the cool soothing mint comes to play, it almost smells like a refreshing shower gel.
On the other hand, Saint Laurent’s Y EDP opens up brightly with crisp, sweet, and green nuances of apple perfectly blended with a spicy ginger aroma. Without the aldehydes, it smells a bit more intense and thicker than the original EDT iteration.
The citrusy bergamot smell tries to peek through, but instead, it only stays in the background adding a refreshingly tangy sense to the green apple aroma.
Overall, with the green sour apple flavor, YSL Y EDP will freshen up your mood right after the first spray.
Which one smells better, then? Well, the aldehyde, ginger, and citrus combo of YSL Y EDT smells a bit too sharp and piercing to me. And if you’re not a fan of zesty citruses, it may smell too synthetic or overbearing to you.
So, I think the fresh green opening of YSL Y EDP smells better than YSL Y EDT’s strong citrusy beginning.
Projection And Longevity
As we all know, the Eau de Parfum version of any fragrance lasts longer than its Eau de toilette version in most cases. This is also true for YSL Y as well. Because its EDP iteration lasts much longer than its original EDT formulation.
YSL Y EDP easily lasts on the skin for more than 12 hours. Conversely, YSL Y EDT will only last about 4-6 hours.
When it comes to projection and sillage, Y EDP outruns the Y EDT again. It projects so well that only 1 or 2 sprays of YSL Y EDP can fill the whole room with its enticing aroma.
Plus, with greater concentration, YSL Y EDP leaves a stronger sillage than YSL Y EDT.
Hence, this lovely cologne surely can get you some attention from pretty ladies whenever you go out wearing it.
YSL Y EDT, on the other hand, projects quite well to make you noticeable among the crowd, but it can never be as strong as the EDP.
So, without a doubt, YSL Y EDP is the winner when it comes to projection and longevity.
Compliment Factor
Both YSL Y EDT and EDP are mass-appealing scents that have their own loyal fan base all over the world.
Well, Y Eau De Toilette smells very refreshing and exciting with all its beautiful notes. Some may find the zesty opening a bit too strong. But people love how the fragrance develops into a sexy, luscious base.
And wearing this EDT from YSL, you’ll definitely receive some good compliments, especially from girls.
On the other hand, with incredible projection and a very attractive scent, YSL Y Eau De Parfumearns compliments right from the start. This amazing-smelling cologne gets me a lot of compliments whenever I wear it before going out.
So, from my own experience, I would say YSL Y EDP will bring up a lot more compliments and praises than its EDT version.
Versatility
YSL Y EDT is a very youthful, light, and refreshing fragrance. The addition of aldehydes with citruses and floral notes gives it an uplifting and cool vibe that goes perfectly in summer or spring.
Well, this fragrance is too light to wear in winter or at night parties, yet you can wear it on warm days of fall to some extent.
On the other hand, you can wear YSL Y EDP all year round for all kinds of occasions, both formal and casual.
The perfect combination of crispy apple with uplifting citruses and florals makes it ideal to wear on warm days of summer or spring.
Rather than coming out powerfully, the citruses are very well-balanced in Yves Saint Laurent’s Y EDP. Plus, it develops beautifully while retaining a warm gourmand character that makes it wearable in cold weather as well.
You can wear this versatile cologne as your daily scent or while going to a formal or casual party. And it will make sure you smell classy and sexy for the whole day or night.
Hence, there is no doubt to say YSL Y EDP is way more versatile than YSL Y EDT.
Value For Money
Despite being two designer perfumes from the house of Saint Laurent, the prices of both Y EDP and EDT are quite reasonable. But still, the EDT version comes at a cheaper price range than the EDP.
For a 100ml bottle of YSL Y EDT, you may need to spend around $55-$75. Conversely, a 100ml YSL Y EDP bottle will cost you around $80-$95.
Although it’s a bit pricier, when it comes to value for money, YSL Y Eau De Parfum has the upper hand for sure. Because it offers better longevity and projection than its Eau De Toilette version.
So, considering the very close price range, in my opinion, YSL Y EDP offers more value for money with its unbeatable performance and lasting power.
Overall Scent
From a very bright opening with powerful aldehyde, bergamot, and ginger, YSL Y EDT develops beautifully into a floral fruity heart.
The combination of apple with violet leaves allows the fragrance to progress with a fresh green and crispy appearance. Then, its core gets a whiff of rich, soft character from the hazy sage and geranium absolute.
Soon, the aroma settles into a woody, musky base with an amber-like undertone. There’s also a slight smokiness of incense that completes the fragrance while making it more sensual and masculine.
YSL Y EDP also develops into a very alluring and mature fragrance from a light and refreshing opening. Its core is very soft aromatic, and hazy with sage and geranium.
The dry-down is the best part of this cologne. It’s very warm, woody, and earthy with all the woodsy ambery base notes. In the end, the smoky spiciness of tonka gives this fragrance a perfect finish.
Overall, YSL Y EDP is an intensely masculine fragrance with a very alluring and classy smell.
Well, both YSL Y colognes smell nice and premium. But in my opinion, YSL Y EDP is better than YSL Y EDT as it develops into a more mature and attractive scent.
Final Verdict
In the world of designer colognes, both the EDP and EDT versions of YSL Y are considered iconic fragrances. You can pick any one of these two YSL gems.
Yet, after comparing, I would say Y Eau De Parfum is better in all aspects, from overall scent and versatility to performance. It may seem a bit more expensive, but it offers more value than the original Y Eau De Toilette.
So, if you ask me to choose one between them, I will always go for the Eau De Parfum version.
Still, if you wanna try a refreshing, light woody scent for short-time use, you can give YSL Y EDT a try for sure.
