When Montblanc Legend EDT first hit the market, many thought no other flanker would be able to beat its popularity. But the introduction of the Legend EDP was enough to prove them wrong.
Both are splendid in their own way and offer quality, performance, and intoxicating facets all at once. Hence, you may struggle to pick one between these two gorgeous Legend formulations.
That’s why I’ll be giving you a detailed comparison of Montblanc Legend EDP and EDT in this article.
So, stay put!
Clash Of Scents: Montblanc Legend EDP vs EDT
Montblanc Legend EDT
Main Notes: Lavender, Pineapple, Bergamot, Red Apple, Dried Fruits, oak moss, Tonka Bean, and Sandalwood
Since 2011, the musky, sweet aroma of Montblanc’s Legend EDT has enchanted fougere scent lovers. Olivier Pescheux formulated this masterpiece as a shout-out to all the passionate and virtuous men.
What I love the most about Legend EDT is its subtle yet seductive masculine presence. Even though it has a refreshingly sweet, fruity start, it soon develops a strong, earthy, musky quality that persists till the end.
Not only that, with the perfect balance of smoky tonka bean and rich sandalwood, it evokes the strength and virility of a man.
So, this can be your top pick when you are looking for a perfect go-to cologne that makes gloomy fall or spring days more energizing.
And for more options like this one, you can try out some other colognes that smell similar to Montblanc Legend.
Montblanc Legend EDP
Main Notes: Violet Leaves, Bergamot, Woodsy Notes, Jasmine, Oakmoss, and Leather
With Olivier Pescheux’s master-class composition, Montblanc introduced the EDP flanker of Legend in 2020. While maintaining the fresh, musky OG DNA, Legend EDP enchants more with its vibrant, woody facets.
It begins with the refreshing and exciting quality of violet leaf that soon turns into a fully mature aroma with oakmoss and woody notes.
Moreover, this crowd-pleaser goes brilliantly with any kind of occasion and weather. My husband wears this cologne whenever he wants to signify his presence in the crowd.
Both Montblanc’s Legend EDP and EDT smell gorgeous and are best-selling colognes from the brand. Which one you should buy then?
To ease your work, I will give you my take on these two legendary colognes. I will also mention their strong and weak points so that you know which one is the one for you.
So, here is my thorough comparison between Montblanc Legend EDP and EDT:
Opening
The original Montblanc Legend EDT has a clean, fruity, sweet appearance from the beginning. The airiness of Lavender joins the juicy pineapple, and together, they lead the opening act with harmony.
A smooth, woody undertone perfectly balances the sweet-citrusy opening so that it never becomes too sharp or overbearing.
And I think Legend EDT comes with the perfect blend of sweet, zesty, and clean accords from the beginning.
Now, let’s move to the Legend EDP, which has a strong, green, airy, somewhat citrusy start with a heavy dose of violet leaf. With a good amount of zesty bergamot, the opening seems energizing, but it still smells kind of generic or flat for the first few minutes.
Both fragrances have a good, refreshing start. But in my opinion, Montblanc Legend EDT will be the winner as it unfolds in a more interesting way.
Projection & Longevity
Both Legend EDP and EDT can help you exert an addictive and longer-lasting effect on your peers.
When it comes to lasting power, Legend EDP definitely has the upper hand. That’s because this cologne stays up for over 8 hours on my husband’s skin.
Other than that, its strong projection can easily attract people standing within a 6-foot radius around you.
However, I wasn’t really impressed by the Legend EDT’s performance. It stays up on the clothes only for 6 hours with arm-length sillage.
It projects well for the first 45 minutes, but then it becomes a merely noticeable skin scent.
So, when it comes to projection and staying power, I will definitely vote for Montblanc Legend EDP.
Compliment Factor
Legend EDT appeals to everyone with its catchy, sweet, refreshing, musky aura. My husband wore this gorgeous scent throughout the last fall. And it brought him tons of compliments from his colleagues and friends.
Legend EDP offers a perfect mix of flowers and sensual woody notes with a hint of leather. Its soothing, masculine trail makes girls fall for it. I won’t say this is a complete crowd-pleaser, but its masculine tone still pulls compliments.
I would say no matter which Montblanc Legend version you wear, you’ll find people saying something nice about your impressive aura.
So, when it comes to bringing compliments, both Legend EDP and EDT will do equally great.
Versatility
Legend EDT comes with a sweet, refreshing quality that slowly leans towards a woody, musky character. For 80% of its life, this cologne stays airy, sweet, musky, and slightly woody, which suits any fall or springtime event.
Its cleanliness goes brilliantly on any formal or casual gatherings, but at the same time, I find it a little bit too intense for summer.
Conversely, Legend EDP is far more versatile than the OG, as you can wear it on any kind of occasion throughout the year. It adapts beautifully and smells gorgeous in both warm and cold weather.
I think its mature, woody, masculine tone compliments the formal or dressy events better. But I’ve seen my husband wearing it to our date nights as well.
All in all, other than any fancy party, you can pretty much cover all your outings throughout the year with a single bottle of Legend EDP.
So, when it’s about versatility, Montblanc Legend EDP will easily surpass the original Legend EDT.
Value For Money
The value a fragrance has to offer against the money spent is really important, especially when you are looking for a scent with a limited budget.
So, let’s find out which one between Legend EDP and EDT offers more value.
Well, both Montblanc cologne comes in 50ml and 100ml bottles, which cost around $85 and $115, respectively. And from discounters or on sale, you can even get them at a lower price. So, both are affordable and cost about the same.
Now let’s find out which offers better value.
Even though Legend EDT has a better opening aroma, Legend EDP lasts longer and is far more versatile.
So, considering the price and performance, Legend EDP is the clear winner in this segment.
Overall Scent
Legend EDT is a symphony of contrasting accords that beautifully evoke the modern masculine vibe.
After the refreshing splash of lavender and pineapple, the fragrance gradually brings in the fresh and delicate tone of some gorgeous flowers. Then, the exciting blend of apples, dried fruits, and oakmoss form an addictive yet warm core.
As time passes, this sweet, airy fragrance completely turns into a musky, woody aroma in the dry-down. Here, the smoky smell of tonka bean mingles with rich, powdery sandalwood, giving the cologne a smooth, masculine, and really pleasing closing.
Legend EDP, on the other hand, carries the sweet, woody DNA of the original while adding more mature and deeper characters to it.
The opening of this one may not fascinate you that much. But as it grows on the skin, Legend EDP will force you to love it. I just love the core, where woody notes create a strong aromatic backbone with some heavenly floral notes.
Keeping the masculine sensation intact, Oakmoss and leather then add a mysterious and cozy charm to the dry-down.
Even though I’m a big fan of the OG, I think the EDP version unfolds much more pleasing and interesting facets.
So, when it comes to overall scent, I will definitely make Legend EDP the winner.
Final Verdict
While Legend EDT is the timeless classic, Legend EDP is the recent hype on the internet. So, picking one between these two is really difficult.
However, if you love clean, sweet, musky colognes with some earthy quality, the original Legend might be the best one for you. It’s affordable, smells attractive, and performs quite well in the fall.
Conversely, Legend EDP has a fresh, woody aura with the right amount of mystery. Plus, it lasts longer and is far more versatile.
So, if you wanna get more value within the same price range, Legend EDP can surely be your endgame.
