Top 9 Fragrances Similar to Myrrh & Tonka by Jo Malone

To feel warm, spicy, and empowering, I can’t think of any fragrance other than Jo Malone’s Myrrh & Tonka. For the last couple of months, I have reached for it over and over again.

Though it’s pretty affordable, I wanted mine to last.

That’s why I looked for the closest alternatives of Myrrh & Tonka and, to my surprise, found quite a number of expensive and budget-friendly clones.

So, if you are like me, keep reading to find your preferred substitute quickly.

What Does Myrrh & Tonka by Jo Malone Smell Like?

Myrrh & Tonka by Jo Malone smells just like its name. After application, you will feel the nutty, resinous, and vanillic aura till the end. And that’s what an amber perfume means. Besides, the refreshing lavender creates a very enchanting atmosphere within your arm’s length.

Perfumer Mathilde Bijaoui created this gorgeous and classy fragrance in 2016.

So, before starting the conversation, let’s see the note formulation of Myrrh & Tonka by Jo Malone:

Top Note: Lavender

Middle Note: Myrrh

Base Notes: Tonka Bean, Vanilla, Almond

This sophisticated fragrance opens with lavender’s delicate, herbal, and floral smell. It’s mood-lifting and gives a boost of energy instantly.

Then, in the heart, the warm, balsamic resinous myrrh starts to spread. And the vibe continues till the end.

As time goes on, the aroma reacts to your skin, and it changes to a more dense and inviting tone.

Furthermore, in the dry-down, the harmonious blend of vanilla with the toasted almondy smell of tonka bean and the buttery and sweet hint of almond is magnificent.

What’s most interesting is that tonka beans smell different depending on the quantity used in the formula. Here, it gives a nutty almondy vibe, and you will also sense the spicy, manly tone at the back. That explains the unisex genre.

Apart from the creamy and smooth base, Myrrh & Tonka by Jo Malone comes with 12 hours of longevity and great sillage.

Also, it’s slightly on the pricier side. Well, it clarifies why Jo Malone perfumes are so expensive. But let me assure you it’s worth your money.

What Fragrances Are Similar To Myrrh & Tonka by Jo Malone?

There are several reasons I wanted to find alternative options to Myrrh & Tonka by Jo Malone. Price range is the main reason, and I also wanted to try out fragrances with a similar vibe yet have a bit different tone.

In that search, I have come across a number of replicas. And my main focus was to compare the accords and notes. Now, I will discuss what I have found so far.

Here are the top 9 dupes of Myrrh & Tonka by Jo Malone:

1. Myrrh & Tonka Cologne Intense Jo Malone London

Whenever I look for smell alikes of a particular aroma, I take a look if there is something from the same brand. This time, I did the same and found the closest substitute for Myrrh & Tonka from Jo Malone.

Myrrh & Tonka Cologne Intense Jo Malone London will be your ideal perfume if you want an intense unisex fragrance.

It was launched in 2019 with several overlapping notes. My friend uses this aroma, and I borrowed it for a day to try. After spraying, I felt myrrh’s intense, sweet, resinous smell, which mingled with the complex, nutty, spicy tone of tonka bean.

There is also the romantic touch of vanilla, which becomes prominent as time goes by.

Additionally, the soft, bitter-sweet aura of almonds makes the dry-down more cozy and heartwarming. All you need is a few sprays, and for 12 hours, you will be tension-free.

When to Wear

Myrrh & Tonka Cologne Intense by Jo Malone is best suited for winter and fall. You can enjoy its passionate aura, whether day or night. Also, you can use it to some extent during the spring and summer.

Why Should You Buy

2. Mr. Sillage Alexandria Fragrances

Mr. Sillage by Alexandria Fragrances is the perfect clone of Myrrh & Tonka by Jo Malone. With exactly the same ingredients, it has the closest tone.

In 2018, this alternative limited edition came to the market with the most ancient luxury perfume-making formula. And it’s dedicated to Chris Georgio, one of the well-known supporters of Alexandria Fragrances.

At the opening, Hany Hafez kept it simple with lavender’s alluring, enchanting aura, which alone is enough to keep you captivated.

Then, slowly, the resinous smell of myrrh takes over. And after the refreshing vibe, this coziness is very appealing for the cold winter days.

Finally, you will feel the amicable mixture of nutty, sweet, and powdery tonka bean, rich syrupy vanilla, and almond with its woody hint. It’s amazing how a few ingredients can create such a breathtaking formulation!

If I knew how to make my own perfume, this would be my first composition. Moreover, it’s suitable for both men and women, but my friend says it’s more masculine.

It depends on the preference, I guess. Because I will definitely use it. With 12 hours of long-lasting service and strong sillage, can you blame me?

When to Wear

For your winter and fall nighttime enlightenment, Mr. Sillage is an ideal pick. It will make your date nights and days unforgettable without being too overwhelming.

Why Should You Buy

3. Mia’s Blend Be Layered

Looking for a straightforward composition in a similar style to Myrrh & Tonka? Then, you will love Mia’s Blend by Be Layered. This amber vanilla perfume was launched in 2019.

You will smell the alluring tonka bean from the very beginning, and thus, you will be happy after applying.

Then, gradually, the bitter, sweet licorice-smelling myrrh mingles with vanilla. And its bitterness gets minimized. Here, lavender also plays a vital role.

Finally, during the end moment, the nuttiness of sweet almonds hits the spot.

In a nutshell, Mia’s Blend is an impressive fragrance that radiates through a whole room and lasts longer (more than 10 hours) with a great price point.

When to Wear

Mia’s Blend Be Layered is mainly a fall-time fragrance. You can also wear this amber vanilla prominent aroma during the cold winter.

Why Should You Buy

4. Pour Un Homme de Caron Le Soir Caron

If your man is searching for a cologne that smells similar to Myrrh & Tonka by Jo Malone. Then, gift him Pour Un Homme de Caron Le Soir by Caron, and he will be over the moon.

Let me explain.

Pour Un Homme de Caron Le Soir is a wintertime scent launched in 2022. And it has its own twist that makes it more interesting.

After spraying, you will sense the powdery, earthy freshness from Orris and lavender. The clean floral touch of lavender will lift your mood and soothe your nerves.

Slowly, the smokey tone of incense blends with the sweetness of vanilla and creates an interesting vibe. I think vanilla makes every note smell wonderful, don’t you think?

After a couple of minutes comes the alluring tone of tonka bean, and in this stage, I felt the sensation of Myrrh & Tonka the most when I tried it.

Apart from cypress, I got the blend of dry, musky ambroxan and fresh herbal violet leaf.

However, Pour Un Homme de Caron Le Soir has moderate sillage and longevity, along with a reasonable price range.

When to Wear

If you want to warm up your lazy winter and fall days and nights, spray a few pumps of Pour Un Homme de Caron Le Soir, and you are good to go. In spring, it’s wearable, too.

Why Should You Buy

5. Fallen Leaves Anna Zworykina Perfumes

Fallen Leaves was formulated by Anna Zworykina in 2007. It has several overlapping notes that make it a replacement for Jo Malone’s Myrrh & Tonka.

At the first sniff, the resinous and woody smell of myrrh and cedar will captivate you. Then, after a few minutes, the mighty tonka bean appears along with the deep, powerful, ambery tone of labdanum and spicy resinous incense.

Also, when the alluring tone of vanilla mingles with cardamom, it slowly brings out the warmth.

In addition, the green, earthy, yet clean smell of patchouli intensifies the powdery floral touch of the iris that I love as a dry-down, which overall lasts for a solid 12 hours with moderate sillage.

When to Wear

The name Fallen Leaves is a clear indication that this perfume is for the fall. So, you can wear this woody aroma for casual outings, dates, or just for running errands.

Why Should You Buy

6. Myrrhnilla Delight by The Dua Brand

A month ago, at a party, I noticed my cousin was smelling like Myrrh & Tonka, but when I asked, she introduced me to Myrrhnilla Delight by The Dua Brand. A delightful fragrance that resembles Myrrh & Tonka by Jo Malone.

It opens with fresh and powdery lavender, which will give you a nice relaxing feeling.

Then, you will sense the mixture of bass-heavy notes, such as sweet yet bitter myrrh and mesmerizing vanilla.

If that’s not enough, there is nutty, herbal tonka bean mingling with the richness of almonds, which makes this alternative perfume ideal for the colder months.

When to Wear

You can wear Myrrhnilla Delight by The Dua Brand for your winter and fall nightouts and parties with your eyes closed.

Why Should You Buy

7. Amethyst Haze Carolina Herrera

So far, you have known about a couple of cost-effective substitutes of Myrrh & Tonka by Jo Malone. Now, let me tell you about an expensive one.

Amethyst Haze by Carolina Herrera was launched in 2021, and the nose behind this sexy and classy perfume is Alex Lee and Véronique Nyberg.

After spraying the first pump, you will smell the resinous, spicy tone of cardamom that elevates when mixed with pink pepper. I really appreciate its rosy undertone as it makes the combination light.

In the heart, the blend flows from refreshing to dark and intense.

Here, lavender is the reason for the freshness, and later coffee becomes more prominent.

Overall, the synthetic, woody, musky aura of cashmere wood in the base mingles with the sweet, cozy vanilla and earthy yet woody patchouli in perfect harmony.

Moreover, this woody, spicy fragrance will give you 12 hours of service with moderate sillage. But keep in mind it’s pretty expensive.

When to Wear

During fall, winter, and spring, Amethyst Haze Carolina Herrera works the best. Especially at night, it flourishes the most, and you can wear it during the daytime as well.

Why Should You Buy

8. Jo Malone Myrrh & Tonka Inspiration by Oil Perfumery

Perfume oil is another practical way to enjoy your favorite aroma. And I found the exact replacement oil of Myrrh & Tonka by Jo Malone.

The brand is called Oil Perfumery.

At first, I was a bit optimistic, but after trying at the shop, I got it immediately. The first reason is the uncanny resemblance, and the second is the affordability.

It comes with the same lavender opening. The scent hits differently as it’s in an oil form.

Then, when it sits on your clothes and skin for a few minutes, the sweet, resinous smell of myrrh becomes very obvious. And I felt, in oil, it became more intense.

Finally, the meticulous mix of nutty, sweet, and almond notes impressed me in the dry down.

The best part is this Myrrh & Tonka-inspired oil extract is very practical, and I can carry it in my purse wherever I want.

Anyway, usually, fragrance oils last longer. The same happened, and I enjoyed this classy clone for 12 hours. It also had a moisturizing touch. But I think the sillage was moderate.

Moreover, if you want to know what perfume oil is, you can check out this context to be more clear.

When to Wear

You can count on Jo Malone Myrrh & Tonka Inspiration by Oil Perfumery to brighten your cozy date nights or casual outings during the colder months.

Why Should You Buy

9. Tonka Reminiscence

The last alternative of Myrrh & Tonka by Jo Malone that I will introduce to you is Tonka by Reminiscence. This amber fragrance came out in 2013.

Though it smells very similar, it has its own twist.

From the beginning, you will get the spicy warmth of clove, sweet greenish anise, with refreshing tangy bergamot. It has every element to soothe your nerves.

Then comes the heart with the richness of honey, which later mingles with the bitter-nutty tone of almond and sweet floral essence.

At the base, the star tonka beans show up in full form. Its nutty, earthy, and woody smell perfectly compliments the animalic musk and sweet smooth vanilla. By applying a few pumps, you will be set for 12 hours with moderate sillage.

When to Wear

During winter and fall days, Tonka Reminiscence works perfectly. If you want, you can wear it during nighttime activities.

Why Should You Buy

Wrap-Up

In the harshness of winter and late fall, the warmth and welcoming vibe of Myrrh & Tonka by Jo Malone is undeniable.

It’s enough to serve you the whole season.

The best part is that it has many alternatives that will give you the same comforting vibe within your budget. Now you can choose which one is best suited for you. Or you can buy multiple dupes and wear them as you wish.

So, get your Myrrh & Tonka replacement, and thank me later.