Colognes Similar to The Tragedy of Lord George Penhaligon's

Tragedy Of Lord George is sweet, boozy, aromatic, and smells like a wealthy man. This fragrance instantly caught my attention when I smelled it for the first time.

However, its price range is something that makes me think twice before buying a whole bottle. And I’m sure many of you had a similar experience.

Hence, I found out the best substitutes for the Tragedy Of Lord George. All of them will give you a similar lord-like feel while staying within the budget.

So, tag along as I’m gonna describe them all here.

What Does The Tragedy Of Lord George Penhaligon’s Smell Like?

The Tragedy of Lord George by Penhaligon’s has an ambery, oriental fougere aroma throughout. It starts with boozy brandy, which further gets a spicy, shaving soap vibe from its aromatic heart. In its base, some woody notes with a hint of Tonka impart classy and noble masculinity.

This cologne is created by master perfumer Alberto Morillas, who is well-known for designing classic masculine fragrances that also embody a modern vibe.

Now, let’s see what notes he used to make Tragedy Of Lord George:

Top Note: Brandy

Middle Notes: Tonka Bean and Lavender

Base Notes: Ambroxan and Woodsy Notes

The start of The Tragedy Of Lord is actually slightly sweet and warm with brandy. However, it is not overly boozy and also has a green, citrusy undertone.

Well, there’s a lot going on at its core. It has the spicy, nutty aspect of tonka bean, along with an aromatic shaving soap vibe from lavender.

But you know what, I could also sense a green herbaceous, woody tone underneath, which makes the aroma incredibly pleasing.

Finally, the dry-down arrives, spreading a wealthy, aristocratic vibe from ambroxan in the base.

Overall, The Tragedy of Lord George is an extremely elegant and manly fragrance that can be your perfect choice for any formal or special event during the fall or early winter.

But I wasn’t quite satisfied with its performance. Even though it costs over $200, the scent lasts only for 4 to 6 hours with moderate sillage.

What Colognes Smell Similar To The Tragedy Of Lord George Penhaligon’s?

The Tragedy Of Lord George is undoubtedly a masterful composition with lots of unique accords. But it gives a classic 80s vibe and doesn’t offer a good value for the price.

Hence, I’ve listed the following alternatives, which retain the smelling tone of Tragedy Of Lord George and add some of their own uniqueness.

And here are my top-picked The Tragedy Of Lord George smell-alikes:

1. Perfume Me 245

Perfume Me 245 is one of the best clones, which I came across while looking for affordable The Tragedy Of Lord George substitutes.

You can get a grasp of their similarities just by looking at the note profile. This fragrance has almost all the notes present in the OG.

The opening feels similarly sweet and boozy, but I couldn’t smell any citrusy undertone in this interpretation.

In the middle, this cologne literally features shaving soap, which was the signature aroma of the original’s heart. Well, it felt a bit synthetic to my nose, but the resemblance is definitely there.

Soon after the mid comes the spicy, woody, and irresistible base.

At this stage, this clone smells 100% similar to its inspiration. Here, I could sense the nutty smell of tonka bean elegantly layered with warm amber and sophisticated, woodsy notes.

Apart from the aroma, Perfume Me 245 also provides a better performance. It stays up for about 6 hours with standard sillage.

But if you look at its price point, the value it offers is just incredible.

When To Wear

You can make your business meetings or any casual to special outings in the fall and winter more luxurious with this beautiful cologne.

Why Should You Buy

2. Noble George Privezarah

Noble George by Privezarah is the next affordable Tragedy Of Lord George dupe in this list. This cologne offers a similar aura, but I must say, sometimes I find its aroma even better than the Penhaligon’s one.

At the first whiff, it will give you an amazing, boozy, sweet feeling of brandy. It is not overwhelming and smoothly blended with some aromatic, green accords.

Brandy stays on for around 15 to 20 minutes, and after that, it starts to settle with a gorgeous, spicy, woody, slightly smoky aroma. I love its powdery, amber-like texture, which gives a cozy experience for hours.

Overall, Noble George is a sweet, spicy, boozy, woody scent for me that can make you feel confident and elegant with just a few sprays.

However, it doesn’t project strongly, but the sillage is noticeable enough to make you stand out among your peers.

When To Wear

Noble George is best suited for any day or nighttime activities during the dry, cold days of winter and fall.

Why Should You Buy

3. Luna Rossa Black Prada

If you loved the amber-tonka combo in The Tragedy Of Lord George, you’ll surely love Luna Rossa Black by Prada. With the amazing composition of Daniela (Roche) Andrier, this cologne has a smooth, warm, creamy sweetness all the way through.

Well, amber is the star of this formulation, and you feel its warm sweetness from the first sniff. The opening is sweet, warm, and very pleasing, with a subtle tangy undertone.

The core is supposed to be green and earthy. Although the green sweetness of angelica was there early on, I couldn’t smell any patchouli in this aroma.

Soon, this scent presents a spicy, warm, woody texture with tonka and amber. This duo evokes an elegant, manly appeal that stays with you for the whole day.

There’s a little bit of musk underneath that gives a dark, intense character to the base.

Luna Rossa Black offers a moderate projection. Instead of becoming a skin scent, it creates a sensual cloud around you.

In my opinion, it offers great value considering the price and quality. However, if you still find it expensive, try out other low-priced colognes similar to Prada Luna Rossa Black.

When To Wear

Luna Rossa Black has a dark and warming sweet character, which works great for date nights, clubbing, or casual parties during the winter.

Why Should You Buy

4. Malakeos Bvlgari

Now, let’s talk about the most liked Tragedy Of Lord George dupe on my list, which is Malakeos by Bvlgari. Jacques Cavallier created this gorgeous scent back in 2016.

In the beginning, Malakeos has a fresh, earthy oakmoss aroma minced with minty, sweet geranium.

Then, aromatic powdery lavender appears after a few minutes, giving the fragrance its fresh fougere nature.

Finally, the base goes through a slightly dark but extremely classy woody, musky aroma with warm ambroxan underneath.

Simply put, Malakeos doesn’t replicate The Tragedy Of Lord George entirely, but it will definitely give you a similar luxurious vibe. And its fresh, aromatic opening even makes the aroma much more pleasant.

So, if you are into good fougere compositions, just go for this one. Plus, Malakeos offers better longevity and sillage at a slightly cheaper price range.

Additionally, if you like this classy scent, I suggest also trying Bvlgari Tygar and all the colognes similar to it.

When To Wear

The fresh yet cozy texture of Malakeos is ideal for any casual or semi-formal events in spring, summer, or fall.

Why Should You Buy

5. Cargo de Nuit Prada

Cargo de Nuit by Prada is my personal favorite in this alternative list. It is clean, sexy, and the dry-down smells almost identical to Tragedy Of Lord George.

It strikes with a floral, musky, iris-like tone that makes the fragrance super clean right from the start. Ambrette is quite detectable in the opening, which blends gorgeously with orris and freesia, creating this classy aroma.

Hedione is well-known for adding sexiness to any fragrance. And Cargo de Nuit features this sexy accord in its heart along with some powdery woody notes such as cedar.

The fragrance becomes even sexier and cleaner with time. During the dry down, it exerts a spicy, woody, slightly musky nuance from the harmony of coumarin, sandalwood, and Iso E Super.

Overall, it is a soapy, clean, expensive-smelling aroma that attracts a lot of compliments from the ladies. Plus, its projection is really strong, and the alluring scent trail stays on the skin for over 10 hours.

This is one of the most versatile scents in my husband’s collection. It may be a bit pricey, but it can make you smell elegant all year round.

So, definitely worth the money.

When To Wear

You can wear Cargo de Nuit to the office, weddings, or any gatherings where you need to smell crisp, clean, and masculine.

Why Should You Buy

6. Bizarre Brandy Molton Brown

Bizarre Brandy by Molton Brown is actually the most underrated dupe of Tragedy Of Lord George. Master of sweet fragrances Karine Dubreuil-Sereni created this gem back in 2019.

When you first spray it, a sweet, spicy, and very creamy aroma will hit your nose, along with a slight citrusy undertone. Even though tobacco is listed in the base notes, I can sense it right from the beginning. It gives a light, smoky vibe to the spicy opening.

When the spicy aroma fades, the booziness of brandy and maple takes over. At this stage, it will give you a refined warmth and coziness.

Then, slowly, it settles on the skin, creating a sweet, smoky, and smooth woody scent trail that lasts over 8 hours on the skin.

This scent always gives off a happy, festive feel, which is another big reason to love it more. Plus, it presents a good projection and sillage at an affordable price range.

So, if you’re looking for a boozy, sweet, spicy cologne for the upcoming Christmas, just have a flacon of Bizarre Brandy.

When To Wear

This is definitely a winter fragrance. You can wear it to events such as parties, family gatherings, or special dinners with colleagues.

Why Should You Buy

Final Thoughts

If you really wanna experience the luxurious feel of The Tragedy Of Lord George while spending less, check out the alternatives listed here.

All of them did a great job replicating this unique composition. And at the same time, they smell gorgeous on their own.

So, no matter which one you pick, you will be satisfied.

However, if you have any further queries, write them down in the comment box.