Sometimes you luckily come across an affordable fragrance that you gradually fall in love with. The next thing you know, you are almost done with the bottle but cannot find the same one anywhere.
To add to the injury, you can’t even find the right substitute for that scent.
Well, this happened to one of our regular readers, who fell in love with Jake by Hollister but couldn’t find any clones of this affordable cologne in the market.
So, I decided to take matters into my own hands and help out my friend in need.
If you love Hollister Jake and want something close to it, then keep reading till the end.
What Does Jake Hollister Smell Like?
Jake by Hollister is a very simple and easy-to-wear men’s cologne. There are not many dimensions to this scent, but there’s no denying the fact that it smells very pleasant.
The main detectable notes in this cologne are citrus and woody notes. The starting is pleasantly bright with a fruity touch of citruses.
Gradually the fragrance develops into a woody, somewhat earthy aroma.
The scent isn’t a groundbreaking invention, but it has a sense of mass appeal, which is responsible for the attention it gets.
It is quite affordable and has quite a flexible usability. You can wear it in summer, spring or fall, as you please.
Even though it is a daytime fragrance, you can also wear it to casual occasions during the evening if you’d like.
The performance of Jake is not bad, not too good either. It lasts around 3 to 4 hours, so you have to keep reapplying it, and the sillage is good at the beginning but goes downhill before long.
What Colognes Are Similar To Jake Hollister?
This aromatic, woody cologne has many similar counterparts in the market – but which ones are the best?
I have tried and tested a range of fragrances that share a similar profile with Hollister Jake in order to find the ones with the closest aroma and best overall scent.
It is safe to say that you will not be disappointed if you try the colognes that I will mention if you really like the aroma of this Hollister fragrance.
So, here are my top picks for colognes that smell like Jake Hollister:
Destination Grand Canyon by Avon
Top Notes: Grapefruit
Middle Notes: Floral Notes
Base Notes: Cedar
The first cologne on the list is Destination Grand Canyon by Avon. Avon is known to produce affordable fragrances with a great overall scent that usually replicates the aroma of other well-known designer fragrances.
Destination Grand Canyon, released in 2015 by Avon, has a very similar scent profile to Hollister Jake. It has a woody base that can be felt throughout the lifetime of the scent.
Like Jake, Destination Grand Canyon opens with bright citrus notes and develops well to create a floral blend.
It isn’t an extraordinary cologne, but the aroma is fresh, cozy and quite wearable.
The performance is quite commendable, given the price of the cologne, and if you are on a budget, I would highly recommend getting your hands on this one.
When to Wear
Destination Grand Canyon by Avon can be worn all year round and throughout the day. But if you ask me, I’d say it works best during the warmer seasons, particularly in the daytime. It is great for casual wear and outdoor activities.
Why Should You Buy
- Similar scent to Jake Hollister.
- Affordable cologne.
- Good longevity.
- Decent performance, given the price point.
CJ Black by Rue21
CJ Black by Rue21, released in 2007, is probably one of the closest clones of Jake Hollister.
It has a similar overall aroma and is extremely affordable – you can get a bottle for less than 30 dollars!
This cologne starts off with citruses and eventually gives rise to a musky, woody fragrance. The aroma is quite uncomplicated; some people might even find it bland.
However, if you like simple summer scents that are masculine and refreshing, then you will like this one.
It doesn’t last for very long, but you can always keep reapplying it, given its cheap price.
When to Wear
CJ Black by Rue21 is ideal for summer and spring, but you can wear it throughout the day. Whether it’s day or night, you can wear it. It is an excellent aroma for everyday wear, but you might want to keep reapplying it in order to make the scent last.
Why Should You Buy
- Close scent to Jake Hollister.
- Very cheap, budget-friendly price.
- Great value for the price.
Mankind Hero by Kenneth Cole
Top Notes: Mountain Air, Lemon and Coriander
Middle Notes: Lavender, Vanilla, Clary Sage and Plum Wood
Base Notes: White Musk, Coumarin, Oakmoss and Amberwood
Released in 2016, Mankind Hero by Kenneth Cole is another cologne that has a scent comparable to Jake Hollister. The overall scent is very similar, with citrus and woody characteristics.
However, Mankind Hero is much more complex and layered. The notes in this cologne are much richer and have detectable dimensions.
The opening is refreshing with bright lemon and coriander – you get a touch of spiciness that makes it quite pleasant.
The heart of the cologne has a sweetness and creaminess brought across by vanilla, plum wood and lavender.
As the cologne develops, you get the warm musk, oakmoss and amberwood that complete the scent.
It lasts around 4 to 6 hours and has a good sillage. Given its price, I think it is an excellent alternative if you want something like Jake Hollister but with more character.
When to Wear
Mankind Hero is wearable – you can wear it any day of the year and any time. It complements the warmer seasons much better. You can also wear it as an everyday cologne if you’d like.
Why Should You Buy
- Similar scent to Jake Hollister.
- Creamier, sweeter alternative.
- Affordable cologne.
- Versatile scent.
- Has a nice spicy touch.
- Good value for the price.
Curve Soul for Men by Liz Claiborne
Top Notes: Bamboo Leaf, Green Apple, Bergamot and Mandarin Orange
Middle Notes: Litchi, Lavender, Violet and Sage
Base Notes: Cedar, Spices, Oakmoss, Sandalwood, Amber and Vetiver
Curve Soul for Men by Liz Claiborne is another cologne that I think sits right on this list. It is refreshing, aromatic, and has a woody undertone that makes it similar to Jake Hollister.
Created by Jean-Marc Chaillan and Loc Dong, this scent is highly layered with a blend of some interesting notes put together.
The beginning of this fragrance is much sweeter because a sweet green apple accompanies it along with the citrus that is common for the colognes on the list.
The core of the scent has pleasant floral notes along with violet and sage.
The closing notes in this cologne create a warm and cozy aftermath. The cedar, oak moss, amber, sandalwood and vetiver work really well together. The addition of spices brings a flavorful aroma to the cologne.
Even though it is not exactly like Jake, it has a similar foundation with a much more developed scent profile.
The projection and sillage of this cologne are quite average, but you can get this at a great price and make great use of it.
When to Wear
Curve Soul for Men by Liz Claiborne is a great summer or spring cologne – but its use is not limited to these seasons. You can also wear this during the cooler seasons, like fall and winter, so it is quite versatile. It is also great for both day and night events.
Why Should You Buy
- Similar style to Jake Hollister.
- Good value for the price.
- Versatile scent.
- Budget-friendly cologne.
- Well-developed aroma.
White Intense by Lomani
Top Notes: Orange, Lemon, Bergamot and Cardamom
Middle Notes: Herbal Notes, Ylang-Ylang and Atlas Cedar
Base Notes: White Musk, Vetiver and Woody Notes
Last but not the least, we have White Intense by Lomani, which is a cologne quite close to Jake Hollister because it has the same aromatic, woody fragrance.
However, it has a lot more notes and layers to the scent.
White Intense is a masculine aromatic scent that opens just like the others on this list – with bright citruses. A pleasant bergamot in this cologne spruces up the beginning even more.
The floral heart has a pleasant creamy aroma that the ylang-ylang and cedar bring. The herbal notes bring in an interesting earthy touch to the scent.
The base notes are again reminiscent of Jake and have warm woody notes along with some musk and vetiver.
It is super affordable, and the performance is great if you consider the price you’re paying for it!
When to Wear
White Intense is fully a summer scent that can also be used in the spring. It is light and airy while also having a woody edge. You can wear this to all sorts of outdoor activities and semi-formal or casual indoor events.
Why Should You Buy
- Similar scent to Jake Hollister.
- Very affordable fragrance.
- Great value for the price.
Wrapping Up
Jake Hollister is a relatively simple fragrance, so finding a cologne that can replicate the simplicity yet be pleasant to your olfactory senses can be tricky.
However, the colognes I mentioned in this article all have a very similar style to the Hollister fragrance, and they bring something new to the table along with the citrus and woody combination we want.
So, whichever cologne you choose to go for, I am sure you will not be disappointed by the scent or the performance. They are all quite affordable and absolutely delightful to wear, especially in the summer.
Now, I hope this article was helpful to you. Let me know which cologne/ perfume I should cover next.
