Bleu de Chanel EDP and YSL Y EDP are two of the most refined and mature blue fragrances for sophisticated men in today’s society.
After their release, both literally shook the foundation of the perfumery world with their alluring aroma. Therefore, you might understand they have enough reasons to compete and claim one is superior to the other.
But the question is how they compare to each other and which one is worth your hard-earned penny.
Let’s dig it out with a detailed comparison in the following context!
Clash Of Scents: Bleu de Chanel EDP Vs YSL Y EDP
Bleu de Chanel EDP
Main Notes: Grapefruit, Lemon, Mint, Pink Pepper, Bergamot, Aldehydes, Ginger, Nutmeg, Jasmine, Melon, Incense, Amber, Cedar, Sandalwood, Patchouli, and Labdanum
Ever since Chanel released Bleu de Chanel EDP in 2014, it has become one of the sexiest fragrances among all the frag heads due to its enhanced, bold, sensual aroma and masculine edge.
Jacques Polge crafted this stunner with his artistic mind that took the sophistication of Bleu de Chanel to a new height.
Its exquisite fusion makes it super versatile, so you can wear it in cold or warm weather during both the day and night. And the best part is that BDC will get you so many compliments as it speaks elegance with royalty.
Moreover, this woody aromatic scent has a lot more depth and exciting attributes than Blue de Chanel’s other interpretations, which gives it much more complexity than one would assume.
YSL Y EDP
Main Notes: Apple, Ginger, Bergamot, Sage, Juniper Berries, Geranium, Amberwood, Tonka Bean, Cedar, Vetiver, and Olibanum
YSL Y EDP is another iconic aromatic fougere cologne that hit the market in 2018 as a seductive fragrance rendition from the brand.
Perfumer Dominique Ropion left no stone unturned to craft this mass-appealing aura that will enchant you from the beginning and hold you firmly into a nice olfactory journey.
From its fresh, striking, fruity-spicy top to its mysterious, woody dry down, every transition of this cologne amazingly provokes a sensual desire to grasp your beloved’s attention.
Also, its sillage and projection are top-notch, so undoubtedly, it gets impressive reactions from everyone standing near or far away.
Now, after having a preliminary idea of both, it’s high time to comprehend their differentiation factors and ultimately find the legend of the blues.
Let’s get into the detailed comparison between Bleu de Chanel EDP Vs YSL Y EDP:
Opening
Both of the colognes radiate a fresh, citrusy vibe in its opening. But as they settle with time, you will spot the differences.
Bleu de Chanel starts with a sweet, zesty aroma of bergamot, lemon, and mouth-watering grapefruit. Here, you will experience a green herbal tint of mint, adding a stimulating vibe to the surroundings.
The slight hint of pink pepper adds a closing pat to bring out the bold, rugged nature of a man.
Conversely, YSL Y EDP opens with a strong, crispy aroma of green apple paired with a fizzy waft of ginger. In the meantime, a citrusy hint of bergamot peeks through the background, ensuring a refreshing, tangy sensation.
With all the striking notes, this cologne hits pretty strongly and swiftly awakens your olfactory senses from the first glimpse.
Both of these colognes offer an energetic vibe in the opening, but the choice depends on your personal preference.
If you are someone who likes a soft, mild opening, go with BDC otherwise, for a strong start, take a stand on YSL Y EDP or other affordable similar colognes.
However, in my opinion, BDC has a much smoother opening, which is appreciated by all.
Projection And Longevity
Over the years, I have tried a lot of fragrances that have a very loud sillage and projection at the opening and then die down during the lifespan of the perfume.
And while purchasing a new fragrance, it’s important to know about these attributes to make an informed choice.
Eager to know which performs like a beast? Read on further.
In the realm of blue fragrance, where uniqueness matters, BDC seems to navigate a well-known path. This masterpiece is known for its decent yet impressive sillage and projection that radiates intimately.
My partner bought this for its tremendous longevity. And to him, the fascinating part is he can travel a long way for 8-10 hours without any reapplication.
On the contrary, YSL Y EDP also offers 10-12 hours with just 2 to 3 presses. The sillage of this mind hooker is far-fetching and strong enough to declare your presence from more than 8 feet.
However, in terms of projection, it shines remarkably for the first 3 to 4 hours, and after that, it becomes close to skin scent.
So you have to get real close to its wearer to catch a whiff!
Even though BDC is a stunning cologne, YSL Y EDP wins performance-wise due to its hypnotizing sillage and eternal longevity.
Compliment Factor
If you are a perfume fanatic, you surely know both of these colognes have a wide appeal in the fragrance world, and their sensational aroma pulls lots of compliments.
So, here I’m going to disclose which one earns more compliments. Let’s start with BDC.
Along with its fresh, cheerful aroma, Bleu De Chanel unleashes a powerful, seductive tone to captivate your soul. It smells much better in the air and will get you so many compliments from everyone.
My husband says whenever he wears BDC during office meetings and presentations, it brings huge appreciation from his colleagues. So you might understand there’s nothing to hate about this gem.
Meanwhile, YSL Y EDP is no less in this compliment game. With the seducing trail, it crazily hooks the attention of young ladies at any party or event.
Its playful sweetness automatically makes this fragrance super addictive, sexy, and a compliment beast that works mesmerizingly during intimate dates.
It’s clear that in the compliment factor, both of these masculine fragrances command attention. So, it’s a tie in this regard.
Versatility
While researching the adaptability of these colognes, I found both of them are extremely versatile to wear throughout the year.
Their fresh, revitalizing aroma is enough to quench your thirst during a hot summer day. Another way around, they also offer a sweet, cozy, warm touch that feels so inviting during a snowy winter night.
So, that might lead to the question, where do they actually overlap? Let me clear it out.
Though they inhabit the same sphere, they differ in accordance with occasions. For instance, you’ll find BDC is an appropriate fit for a formal environment while it also goes well in casual setups like hangouts or parties.
On the flip side, YSL Y EDP is an outstanding, tempting aroma for your nightlife activities, such as while you are hitting the clubs, date nights, or parties.
Now the question is, which has better adaptability?
Without any doubt, BDC is more versatile and inoffensive for different occasions.
Value For Money
Pricing of fragrances might vary from brand to brand, but what makes them user-friendly is their available sizing options.
Apparently, both of these colognes are marketed in 3 different sizes. Thereby it’s so obvious you are going to find the one that fits your budget.
Let’s talk about BDC first.
Last month, my partner bought the largest 150ml flacon of BDC for $184. But, if you are looking for smaller sizes like 50ml and 100ml, you can find them ranging between $125 to $150.
Conversely, YSL Y EDP also has three different options, which are 60ml, 100ml, and 200ml. The brand retails the smallest size for around $123, while for the other 100 and 200 ml, you have to pay about $148 and $199, respectively.
So, considering smooth opening, compliment factor, and versatility, Blue de Chanel offers great value for money.
Overall Scent
Well, So far, you have already seen a cut-throat competition between Bleu de Chanel vs YSL Y in each segment. Now, it’s the right moment to determine how they smell throughout the journey.
Bleu de Chanel unfolds with a strong, tangy aroma of lemon, bergamot, and grapefruit at the top.
Together, they create an alluring sensation that’s further enhanced with the optimal balance of herbal mint, striking pepper, and soapy aldehydes.
A strong, fizzy hint of ginger merges with the sensual nutmeg to leave a spicy warmth in its heart. Meanwhile, the fruity-floral melody of jasmine and melon makes it more addictive and alluring.
To me, BDC really shines in its dry down. Here, the masculine cedar brings a manly hunch along with the warm, resinous amber and labdanum. Where patchouli draws the most exciting and exotic closing.
In the case of YSL Y EDP, its opening delighted me with the apple’s green nuance and the citrusy burst of bergamot.
Though the opening is a bit synthetic and strong, ladies love YSL Y’s EDP version over the EDT on their man due to its youthful tone.
Juniper berries give it a jammy and sweet fruitiness in the core, followed by sage and fruity floral geranium.
At last, the sweet, woody fusion of cedar and amber makes the dry down more enticing. Also, the nutty gourmand tonka and celestial olibanum set a dreamy ambiance that’s hard to resist.
Overall, both colognes give you a nice encounter in every transition, but to me, BDC feels more settled and well-balanced without any overpowering notes.
Final Verdict
Good manners and a good cologne are what transform a man into a gentleman. So, it’s important to select a cologne that suits your personality.
Well, when the battle is between Bleu de Chanel EDP and YSL Y EDP, it can be pretty baffling. And trust me, you can’t go wrong with either.
Anyway, if you want my preference, I personally enjoy BDC due to its versatility and bold yet subtle aroma. But in case you want to experience something exotic, tempting, and playful, YSL Y EDP will be the icing on your cake.
So choose according to your criteria and enjoy. Adios!
