Best 5 Perfumes Similar To Vanilla Cake Montale [2024]

My sister loves perfumes that are rich in vanilla notes. I wanted to buy her a vanilla-based fragrance on her last birthday.

While researching, Vanilla Cake by Montale seemed to be the best pick for her. But, it was out of my budget and I had to look for something similar.

So, I did a deep dive and discovered some amazing Vanilla Cake EDP dupes.

I will include the substitute in this article. If you want to learn about them, tag along!

What Does Vanilla Cake Montale Smell Like?

Montale Vanilla Cake opens with a sweet lactonic smell of milk and a smokey-nutty hint of roasted almond. Then, it starts to radiate a rich syrupy aroma of vanilla layered with a gourmand caramel hint. It dries down with a lingering aura of creamy meringue accords.

This creamy, milky vanilla-centric perfume was released in 2018. You can use this in winter and fall for long-lasting performance and room-filling delicious velvety sensation.

Now, let’s take a look at the notes profile of Montale Vanilla Cake:

Notes: Meringue, Milk, Madagascar Vanilla, Caramel, Almond

The opening of Vanilla Cake comes with a sweet, milky smell. Its enchanting lactonic vibe will give an intense whiff to your surroundings.

Then, almond comes in bringing a nutty aroma that has an alluring smokey hint underneath. Also, caramel incorporates the crispy nutty aura with a gourmand, bitterish sugary touch.

In the base, an intense syrupy sensation of Madagascar vanilla comes to light along with a mouth-watering creamy twist of meringue.

As the fragrance matures, its dry-down aroma makes me crave my favorite vanilla cake with the creamiest Swiss meringue topping.

This delicious and smooth perfume lasts for 10-12 hours and leaves enormous sillage and projection.

What Perfumes Are Similar To Vanilla Cake Montale?

Montale’s Vanilla Cake is truly enjoyable if you are into heavy gourmand perfumes. Otherwise, it might be a little extra for some.

But don’t worry. In case you are looking for something similar with some added twist to balance the intense sweet accords, check the following section.

Here are the top 5 perfumes that smell like Montale Vanilla Cake:

1. Prada Candy by Prada

Prada Candy is one of the first designer fragrances I bought. It closely resembles the smell of Vanilla Cake EDP.

At the top, Prada Candy unfolds an enjoyable bitterish, sweet aroma of caramel. Its bitter yet sugary hints create an engaging vibe.

In a while, at heart, a soft and soothing powdery sensation comes to light along with a creamy musky aura. They merge with the lingering caramel note giving this fragrance a complex but very alluring touch.

On dry-down, a sweet and syrupy vanillic aura starts to reveal its prominence. Benzoin intensifies the vanilla accords with its resinous nuance.

Apart from its yummiest and attractive smell this substitute for Montale Vanilla Cake lasts up to 12 hours with strong sillage and projection.

Thus, even to this day whenever I apply it, I receive immense praise and attention.

When to Wear

Prada Candy has an intense gourmand smell. It is suitable for the fall and winter. You can use this perfume both in the day and night events.

Why Should You Buy

2. Vanilla S*x Tom Ford

So, this newest launch is already hyping the perfumery world enough. I already got a sample of Tom Ford’s Vanilla S*x.

Its similarities with Montale Vanilla Cake have stunned me. I would definitely buy it, if this stunner was released back when I was looking for the replacements of the OG.

Vanilla S*x opens with an alluring burnt nutty smell of bitter almonds. Its opening gives a slightly intoxicating feel to my senses.

Then, this smokey aroma mingles with a syrupy vanillic nuance in the core. Their combination creates a delicious, mouth-watering vibe. It makes me crave my favorite caramel-nut pie!

Also, an added floral touch balances the scent from becoming too cloying.

The base of this fragrance has a unique twist of different vanilla notes. Firstly, a rich, deep, sweet, and slightly chocolaty hint comes from the vanilla absolute accords.

There, ultravanil enhances the opulent vanillic aroma and tonka bean emits a sizzling spicy nuance in this phase. Plus, sandalwood releases an enchanting buttery-timbering sensation that helps to linger it for up to 10 hours.

This alluring scent has made so much good impression within a short time, but the price point is burdensome for many. Thus, users often look for similar perfumes to Tom Ford Vanilla S*x.

When to Wear

Vanilla S*x is a must-have perfume for cold, snowy weather. It’s the best option for casual outings in any ambiance from morning to night.

Why Should You Buy

3. Coco Vanille Mancera

Coco Vanille by Mancera was launched in 2016. This ambery-vanilla creation by Pierre Montale is another lovely alternative to Vanilla Cake EDP.

The top layer of Coco Vanille unfolds a satisfying and delicious creamy aroma of coconut layered with the juicy essence of white peach fruits.

In a few moments, it flourishes with an opulent floral sensation of ylang-ylang and jasmine. Also, Jasmine’s mind-hooking blossomy aura has a sensual touch underneath.

During dry-down, this fragrance replicates the vibe of Montale’s Vanilla Cake with a syrupy, smokey hint of Madagascar vanilla and creamy white musk.

Moreover, its captivating woody base gives attention-luring projection and enormous sillage for up to 10 hours.

So far, many brands have tried imitating similar perfumes to Mancera Coco Vanille, and some of them are really close to it.

When to Wear

Coco Vanille is a versatile gem. Thus you can use this perfume all year. Also, it will suit your office and casual looks perfectly.

Why Should You Buy

4. Italica (2021) Xerjoff

I find Italica (2021) by Xerjoff as a worthy alternative to Vanilla Cake Eau De Parfum. This best-performing gender-neutral perfume is a must-have for unique scent lovers.

Italica EDP opens with an aromatic smell of saffron alongside a slightly spicy hint. It soon gets replaced by a sweet, lactonic aroma and a delicious nutty tinge.

During the opening phase, its almond notes infuse a smokey, bitterish vibe that reminds me of Montale’s Vanilla Cake.

At heart, toffee and bourbon vanilla come in releasing a deep gourmand sensation with their syrupy and creamy facets. It remains on the skin for a long time and gradually merges with the base notes.

In the base, the blend of sandalwood and white musk produces a velvety, buttery, woody aroma that projects within a big radius..

If your budget isn’t tight, I recommend buying this stunner or trying similar perfumes to Xerjoff Italica (2021).

When to Wear

Italica (2021) is the best fit for colder climates. I like applying this at night to family gatherings or friend meetups.

Why Should You Buy

5. Boardwalk Marshmallow Clouds Bath & Body Works

If you are looking for an affordable dupe of Montale Vanilla Cake, try Boardwalk Marshmallow Clouds by Bath & Body Works.

This inexpensive gem is not a clone but smells quite the same as vanilla Cake EDP and performs amazingly.

Boardwalk Marshmallow Clouds unleashes a rich, syrupy nuance of vanilla in the opening. Plus, it has a mind-seizing, floral aroma of white magnolia that injects a sensual feel with every whiff.

Then, it gradually flourishes with an intense creamy sensation of marshmallow, whipped cream, and meringue. Their sugary, velvety touch induces my cravings for a delicious vanilla cake.

In the dry-down, sandalwood’s buttery-wooded aura trails for at least 6-7 feet distance for 7-8 hours.

When to Wear

Boardwalk Marshmallow Clouds can be used all year. I think it’s the best choice to layer under other perfumes in winter.

Why Should You Buy

Final Thoughts

Montale’s Vanilla Cake is a remarkable perfume, in the gourmand genre. It’s the kind of fragrance that will make your mood right within a few minutes. Thus, there is a good amount of hype regarding this masterpiece.

In case you want to use any dupe of Vanilla Cake Montale, without any hassle select one from the previous section.

That’s all for today. Goodbye.