Good Girl perfume offers the most sexy oriental combination that I’ve ever used. The floral softness and woodsy boldness express the duality of modern women.
But after using this perfume for so many years, I wanna try something new, whether a similar vibe or just the general style to spice up my taste buds.
Well, if you’re also looking for some top-notch alternatives to Good Girl, read till the end. Here, I rounded up the best 10 substitutes that have similar styles with some interesting twists.
So, stay tuned!
What Does Good Girl Carolina Herrera Smell Like?
Good Girl is a floral woody fragrance by Carolina Herrera. It’s a pleasing and appealing composition of soothing tuberose and bold tonka bean. In a word, this fragrance feels like a white blossomy wave with a warm, woodsy touch in heavy winter.
Louise Turner and Quentin Bisch created Good Girl in 2016. This addictive fragrance comes with a tagline that is, “It’s so good to be bad.”
After using this frag as a signature perfume for so many years, I found it very cozy yet elegant. I would say it’s my favorite gourmand scent, period!
And it’s a very sophisticated and classic fragrance that you can wear on any occasion gracefully.
To know the smelling tone, it’s better to look at the notes profile of Good Girl:
Top Notes: Almond, Coffee, Bergamot, Lemon.
Middle Notes: Tuberose, Jasmine Sambac, Orange Blossom, Orris, Bulgarian Rose.
Base Notes: Tonka Bean, Cacao, Vanilla, Sandalwood, Musk, Patchouli.
If you like fresh, fruity openings, this perfume will surely impress you by offering a sweet, juicy, zesty aroma at the top. Almond and coffee add some nutty, smoky essence that makes this fragrance more sexy.
As time passes, in the heart, tuberose and jasmine sambac float with floral accords and a citrusy undertone of orange blossom. Meanwhile, a slight touch of Orris and rose add a boldness to it.
Finally, as it dries, this perfume spreads a woody, spicy aroma of tonka bean, along with a sweetness of cacao and vanilla.
Sandalwood and musk leave a warm, addictive trail behind it. Personally, I love the patchouli hint, which makes this closing more captivating and sexy.
In a word, it’s a perfect composition of sweet, fruity, flowery, and woodsy accords.
I found it best for romantic date nights where I want to create some passionate moments with my boyfriend. Not only that, you can use Good Girl at winter/fall night parties and formal get-togethers with office colleagues.
On top of that, this best-smelling Carolina Herrera perfume also provides 10+ hours of longevity and projects really well.
What Perfumes Similar To Good Girl Carolina Herrera?
If you love the fascinating aroma of Good Girl Carolina Herrera and are looking for some alternatives with innovative hints, try these options.
In this segment, I’ve described 10 dupes that I found after immense testing and thorough market research.
Let’s check out my substitute list for Good Girl:
1. Good Girl Légère Carolina Herrera
Top Notes: Ylang-Ylang, Mandarin Orange, Bergamot, Lemon.
Middle Notes: Tuberose, Jasmine, Orange Blossom, Bulgarian Rose.
Base Notes: Dulce de Leche, Praline, Tonka Bean, Sandalwood, Musk, Patchouli.
Good Girl Legere is the nearest alternative that offers a similar amber floral appearance to the original one. This fragrance was created in 2018 by Louise Turner.
Carolina Herrera introduced this perfume as a lighter version of 2016’s Good Girl.
So this perfume will present a sophisticated and pleasing scent without any heavy accords.
A vibrant, citrusy aroma will greet you when you first spray it. Along with the pungency, a mixed floral touch of ylang-ylang impresses your olfactory sense.
The core is filled with overloaded blossomy notes of tuberose and jasmine. A deep, rosy flavor of Bulgarian rose makes this middle more refreshing yet appealing.
Last, the sweet, creamy texture of Dulce de leche creates an amazing composition with woody, earthy accords of tonka bean and praline. The musky, woody base offers the same vibe as Good Girl, but Dulce de leche makes it slightly sweeter.
After using it, I would say it’s a bit sweeter and more feminine version of the OG. Plus, this perfume also stays up to 10 hours on my skin with moderate projection and sillage.
When to Wear
The woody, ambery aroma of Good Girl Legere is perfect for winter and autumn nighttime use. However, due to its zesty vibe, you can wear this fragrance at early spring evening parties.
Plus, you can use this perfume in every type of event.
Why Should You Buy
- Closest dupe of Good Girl.
- Sweet and refreshing smell.
- Suitable for any occasion.
- Compliments getter.
- Sophisticated yet addictive.
2. Miss Dream La Rive
Top Notes: Black Currant, Cassis, Exotic Fruits, Bergamot.
Middle Notes: Milk, Jasmine, Sandalwood, Magnolia, Rose.
Base Notes: Tonka Bean, Vanilla.
Launched in 2018, Miss Dream by La Rive is perfect for those who wanna try a budget-friendly dupe of Good Girl. It’s like a stronger & spicier rendition of GG Carolina Herrera.
It has a fruity, zesty opening with a soft, spicy hint of cassis. Where the luscious fruity flavor of black currant is the prominent one.
Then, this refreshing citrusy aroma turns into a milky flavor in the core. At the same time, you will also get a woody floral smell with an elegant twist of rose petals.
During dry-down, the perfume presents a mesmerizing combination of tonka bean and vanilla, which propagates a rich, warm, woody, vanillic nuance. Interestingly, this simple yet iconic closing leaves an amazing trance on your body.
When to Wear
Miss Dream is perfect for day and night use in snowy weather. However, you can apply this perfume on spring night outs with your partner.
Why Should You Buy
- Great value for money.
- Outstanding performance.
- Sweet and simple aroma.
- A balanced blend of fruity and woody accords.
3. Dahlia Bath & Body Works
Dahlia is a floral-inspired perfume by Bath & Body Works. This blossomy substitute for Good Girl was launched in 2020. And It also comes with a reasonable price tag.
Though it has a different note profile, you will get the Good Girl vibe from it.
I love the sweet & subtle fruity opening. After a few moments, the perfume presented a rich gourmand aroma of praline with a caramelized nutty undertone.
And finally, the fragrance finishes off with a blossomy nuance of dahlia. In this closing, you will receive the combined floral fruity essence, where praline plays the leading role.
In my opinion, it is the interesting and inoffensive dupe of Good Girl. And this perfume also provides a moderate 6 hours of longevity and sillage.
When to Wear
Dahlia is ideal for fall day and nighttime use, but you can wear this perfume in winter and spring, too.
However, I do not recommend this on heavy winter and warm sunny days.
Why Should You Buy
- Affordable substitute for Good Girl.
- Balanced fruity-floral aroma.
- Perfect for every type of occasion.
4. Mademoiselle Rochas Couture Rochas
Top Notes: Pear, Pink Pepper, Bergamot.
Middle Notes: Heliotrope, Orange Blossom, Lily-of-the-Valley.
Base Notes: Tonka Bean, Sandalwood, Musk.
Mademoiselle Rochas Couture is a woody fougere fragrance by Rochas. Anne Flipo created this masterpiece in 2019 for modern ladies.
It has an uplifting, fruity, spicy beginning layered with a citrusy aroma of bergamot. The juicy fruitiness of pear and bergamot makes the top more appealing.
Similar to Good Girl, it has a white flowery heart. The mixed combination of heliotrope and lily-of-the-valley presents a soothing accord, whereas orange blossom adds a citrusy nuance to it.
In the end, the warm, woodsy, musky aroma creates depth and sensuality. This whole floral mixture smells so nice and relaxing that it can easily captivate your partner. Plus, the addictive woody notes offer warmth in heavy winter.
Moreover, Mademoiselle Rochas Couture also stays up to 10 hours on my skin with noticeable perfume sillage.
When to Wear
It is perfect for any kind of event in the cold season, whether casual or formal. Plus, you can use it as your signature perfume in winter and fall.
Why Should You Buy
- 10+ hours of longevity.
- Addictive dry-down.
- Perfect for day and night use.
- A good example of a woody fragrance.
5. Good Girl Glitter Collector Carolina Herrera
Top Notes: Almond, Coffee.
Middle Notes: Tuberose, Orris, Jasmine.
Base Notes: Tonka Bean, Cacao, Vanilla, Sandalwood.
Next, I’ve another Carolina Herrera fragrance on my alternative list named Good Girl Glitter Collector. Perfumer Louise Turner created this amber floral feminine perfume in 2017.
It is the limited edition of the Good Girl series that also comes in a sparkling-colored flacon.
In the opening, this perfume bursts off with a nutty flavor of almond, along with a noticeable coffee essence. For me, the smokiness of coffee is the most attractive portion of this top.
40 to 50 minutes later, this perfume offers floral accords from tuberose & jasmine. Where a powdery effect of Orris mild down the overpowering blossomy accords and makes the mid more appealing yet sophisticated.
And it settles with a woody vanillic aroma with the sweetness of cacao. This dry-down reminds me of the campfire and hangouts with my friends in Alaska.
Apply 3 to 4 splashes of this rich scent, and it lasts over 12 hours on your skin with heavy projection.
When to Wear
Good Girl Glitter Collector is ideal for winter day and nighttime use. I found it best for romantic special nights or blind dates where you wanna impress your partner with your sexy & enchanting aura.
However, it can be a good option for fall casual hangouts and semi-formal night parties.
Why Should You Buy
- Outstanding longevity and sillage.
- Addictive aroma.
- Perfect for snowy weather.
- Best for romantic dates.
- Compliment magnet.
6. I Want Choo Forever Jimmy Choo
Top Notes: Bitter Almond, Rose.
Middle Notes: Cherry, Vetiver, Jasmine.
Base Notes: Vanilla, Tonka Bean, Oakmoss, Amber.
I Want Choo Forever is a timeless fragrance by Jimmy Choo. It is the fruitier version of Jimmy Choo EDP, which is also considered the best-smelling women’s perfume of Jimmy Choo.
Sonia Constant and Louise Turner invented this fruity floral masterpiece in 2022.
From its first sniff, you will get a nutty, fruity aroma with a dry floral undertone of rose. Then, it drastically changes into a sweet, juicy aroma of cherry in the core. Vetiver adds a woody texture that expresses women’s empowerment.
Finally, this frag offers a warm, rich, woody composition of vanilla and tonka bean.
The base is pretty similar to the dry-down of Good Girl, which also leaves an attractive trail behind it.
When to Wear
I Want Choo Forever is a versatile fragrance that you can use for any type of occasion in fall/winter. But I found it best for a romantic candlelight dinner with my boyfriend.
Why Should You Buy
- Sexy yet modest fragrance.
- Warm, tempting dry-down.
- Impressive aura for chilly weather.
- Interesting opening.
7. Deep Garden Zara
Top Note: Pear.
Middle Note: Tuberose.
Base Note: Tonka Bean.
Deep Garden was launched in 2018 by Zara. It is a pure amber floral fragrance that I found the most simple yet classy dupe of Good Girl.
The flowery perfume starts with a blast of juicy fruitiness of pear. Though there is no citric element, you will still feel a zesty presence at the top.
After a few moments, the fragrance presents a prominent floral accord of tuberose that will absolutely dazzle your surroundings, including your partner.
Ultimately, Deep Garden settles with a sweet, spicy, nutty flavor of tonka bean layered with a woody undertone.
From my perspective, it’s the must-try option for young girls or teenagers. This perfume also offers a standard 6 hours of longevity with noticeable sillage.
When to Wear
Deep Garden by Zara is a spring fragrance. And you can wear it in formal and casual gatherings or as your signature perfume for the whole spring.
Along with that, you can also use this scent on summer night parties and fall days out.
Why Should You Buy
- Affordable dupe of Good Girl.
- Perfect for office wear.
- Best spring fragrance.
- Sweet and feminine perfume.
- Praiseworthy.
8. Good Girl Velvet Fatale Carolina Herrera
Top Notes: Almond, Coffee, Lemon, Bergamot.
Middle Notes: Tuberose, Jasmine, Bulgarian Rose, Orris, Orange Blossom.
Base Notes: Praline, Cacao, Tonka Bean, Vanilla, Patchouli, Musk.
With so many similar accords, Good Girl Velvet Fatale is another substitute for OG Good Girl. Caroline Herrera Launched this amber floral fragrance in 2018.
Louise Turner created this limited edition, which expresses the desire for a Good Girl who wants to be an attraction expert.
I just enjoy the nutty, citrusy opening with the smoky bitterness of coffee. It has a more bold and appealing top than Good Girl.
In the heart, the perfume offers a soothing white floral smell of tuberose, jasmine, and orange blossom. Meanwhile, a slight powdery touch of Orris calms down overwhelming flowery accords and presents a sweet, subtle aroma.
Finally, the base gives a woody, earthy smell along with a sweet creaminess of vanilla and musk. Patchouli adds a boozy effect and makes the closing more alluring for your beloved. I have to admit, this is the best dry-down I’ve smelled yet.
Nevertheless, it has enormous sillage and projection along with great longevity and leaves an amazing trail behind you.
When to Wear
This heavy, woody, musky aroma is perfect for nightwear in winter and fall. In my opinion, it is best for romantic date evenings and formal parties where you want to mark your presence with an enchanting aura.
Why Should You Buy
- Suitable for cold nights.
- Amazing woody floral fragrance.
- Balanced coffee composition.
- Outstanding sillage.
- Sexy & addictive dry-down.
9. The Pride of Armaf For Women Armaf
Top Notes: Orange Blossom, Jasmine, Mandarin Orange.
Middle Notes: Almond, Coffee.
Base Notes: Cacao Pod, Tonka Bean, Patchouli.
The Pride of Armaf For Women by Armaf is another affordable clone of Good Girl that also carries a similar style.
This amber floral perfume has a luminous white flowery opening of orange blossom and jasmine. In the meantime, mandarin orange makes this top more cheerful by adding a zesty hint to it.
As time passes, you will receive a sweet, nutty smell in the core with a distinguishable coffee extract.
During dry-down, this perfume spreads a spicy, herbaceous woodsy essence and a sweet floral aroma of cacao pod. Similar to Good Girl, it also reveals a heady nuance of patchouli that makes this portion more alluring and mesmerizing.
Although it lasts as long as other perfumes do, the sillage and projection of this fragrance are amazing.
When to Wear
The Pride of Armaf For Women is great for cold weather, it offers warmth on freezy nights. However, it can be worn in early spring special date events.
Why Should You Buy
- Wonderful sillage and projection.
- Comes with an affordable budget.
- Great famine fragrance for romantic dates.
- Sweet and subtle aroma.
10. Floratta Red O Boticário
Top Notes: Red Berries, Apple, Orange.
Middle Notes: Floral Notes, Tuberose, Orange Blossom, Violet, Lotus.
Base Notes: Dark Chocolate, Amber, Musk, Sandalwood, Cedar.
O Boticário released Floratta Red in 2019 as an amber floral fragrance. Alienor Massenet is the nose behind this fascinating composition.
From its first sniff, you will get an opulent luscious fruity smell with a sweet citrusy existence of orange. You can say, It’s a little bit sweeter version of Good Girl.
A delightful blend of floral notes and tuberose with a slightly citric aroma arrived in the core. A powdery calmness of violet built the middle alluring without being offensive.
Then the floral accords drastically convert into a bold chocolaty flavor as its base. Not only that, but you also receive an amber-woody smell with a musky velvety feel. For me, the chocolaty twist makes this base more seductive and captivating.
Plus, this sweet rendition of Good Girl also stays up to 7 hours on my skin and projects moderately.
When to Wear
Its dark woody chocolaty composition makes Floratta Red great for winter day and night use. Yet you can wear this perfume on spring night parties with your friend and lover.
Why Should You Buy
- Brings good compliments.
- Ideal substitute for Good Girl.
- Fascinating chocolaty twist.
- Sweet juicy opening.
- Sexy and pure feminine vibe.
Final Thoughts
Undoubtedly, Good Girl is a timeless amber floral fragrance that already captures many hearts by giving its attractive aroma. And finding the perfect replica of this mesmerizing fragrance is a hard nut to crack.
However, I’ve described 10 substitutes that also provide amazing performance, and some of them also come with an affordable price.
Each and every alternative is perfect for romantic dates to enchant your loved one.
So without further ado, choose any of them that goes with your requirements and enjoy!
