To smell mysterious and unique, Carlisle by Parfums de Marly is a great way to go. But its price point is a bummer if you are on a budget or want a similar vibe with a twist.
Fortunately, there are a number of alternative colognes that smell close to this projection beast.
In this context, I have accumulated the closest dupes of Carlisle that last longer and feel amazing during the colder months.
So, without any further ado, let’s get started.
What Does Parfums de Marly Carlisle Smell Like?
Parfums de Marly Carlisle has a very seductive aroma that you will feel from the top to the base. Slowly, the beautiful formulation makes its presence known. With the nutmeg from the opening, the floral yet spicy middle, and sweet, woody dry down, this fragrance is mindblowing.
The intensity and warmth of this scent is perfect for enjoying the cold of winter. But, in summer, it will be overwhelming.
Let’s see how Carlisle’s notes work:
Top Notes: Nutmeg, Green Apple, Saffron
Middle Notes: Tonka Bean, Rose, Davana, Osmanthus
Base Notes: Patchouli, Vanilla, Opoponax
The main highlight of the top is green apple and nutmeg. The fresh, juicy nuance of apple goes well with sweet, spicy nutmeg.
After a few more minutes, you will also get saffron’s soft, intimate touch.
In the heart, the alluring smell of nutty, herbaceous tonka bean increases due to the presence of a powdery, clean aura of rose—the sharp, bitter herbal scent of davana and the soft, sensual milky aura of osmanthus.
This scent will slowly grow on you as time passes, and its modern perfumery hits the spot.
Finally, the base is enriched with fierce combinations like dark, earthy, sweet patchouli, vanilla, and balsamic opoponax that create an intoxicating, boozy aroma that lasts longer than 12 hours.
Moreover, if you are into this brand, you can check out the best smelling Parfums de Marly colognes to add something new to your perfume collection.
What Colognes Are Similar To Parfums de Marly Carlisle?
When it comes to Parfums de Marly, several brands have launched fragrances that resemble Carlisle. And some did a fantastic job in cloning this seductive scent.
Here, I have a list that will make your way easy to select your preferred replica of PDM Carlisle.
Let’s find out the smell-alikes of Carlisle by Parfums de Marly:
1. Red Tobacco Mancera
Top Notes: Cinnamon, Agarwood (Oud), Saffron, Incense, Nutmeg, Green Apple, White Pear
Middle Notes: Patchouli, Jasmine
Base Notes: Tobacco, Madagascar Vanilla, Amber, Guaiac Wood, White Musk
When I smelt Carlisle, the name Red Tobacco came to mind at first. This spicy, woody cologne my partner owns has many overlapping notes.
At the top, you will smell the mixture of agarwood and cinnamon with saffron, which is known for its intimate, earthy aroma that lingers around you and works as a mood-lifting element.
Other components include resinous floral incense, fruity apples, and juicy sweet pears.
Slowly, after a while, comes the heart with its simple blend of woody, earthy patchouli and charming jasmine.
To be honest, I like the middle. It flows from sweet to musky, which attracts me the most.
From the base, I got the aroma of smoky tobacco and sweet, warm vanilla, which tends to last. Then, slowly, I sensed a woody, ambery aura that ended in a musky tone.
Moreover, if you want to try other colognes similar to Mancera Red Tobacco, go ahead. You will not be disappointed.
When to Wear
Winter and fall nights are the best time to enjoy Red Tobacco Mancera in full swing. Avoid wearing it during the summer.
Why Should You Buy
- Lasts more than 12 hours.
- Fresh and intoxicating aroma.
- Strong sillage.
- Top quality ingredients.
- Warm and creamy tone.
- Great performance.
- Budget-friendly.
2. Triumph Of Bacchus Argos
Top Notes: Rum, White Peach, Green Apple, Saffron
Middle Notes: Tonka Bean, Patchouli, Vetiver, Jasmine
Base Notes: Tobacco, Vanilla, Amber, Sandalwood, Musk
If you are looking for an amber spicy fragrance for winter that will resemble Parfums de Marly Carlisle, then Triumph Of Bacchus by Argos, inspired by the last Olympians, will save your day.
This long-lasting complex scent is formulated by Christian Petrovich.
The complex aroma of rum blends with the fruity notes and saffron’s softness at the first sniff.
In the heart, the tone becomes dense and rich due to the presence of sweet, herbal tonka bean, musky patchouli, and clean, earthy vetiver. The floral tone makes the mixture project strongly.
Eventually, you will smell the sweetness of vanilla along with the rich tobacco, amber, and musk.
With just a few pumps, you will be set for more than 10 hours for your special occasions.
When to Wear
Triumph Of Bacchus Argos is a versatile aroma that works well all year round. But fall and winter nights are the ideal time for this fragrance.
Why Should You Buy
- Radiates up to 6 feet.
- Ideal as a gift.
- Good performance.
- A lovely unisex fragrance.
- Affordable.
- Long-lasting.
3. Mystery Tobacco Carolina Herrera
Top Notes: Ginger, Osmanthus, Citruses, Artemisia
Middle Notes: Tobacco, Patchouli, Guaiac Wood, Vetiver
Base Note: Tonka Bean
With woody, warm, and spicy accords, Mystery Tobacco works as a replacement for PDM Carlisle. And it was launched in 2016.
It opens with a spicy ginger kick and a soft, milky tone of osmanthus, mingling with citruses to give a fresh touch.
Quentin Bisch mixed vetiver with tobacco to spice up the fragrance in the middle. You will definitely feel the aura of vetiver and wood in no time.
Finally, this smooth and refined cologne dries down with the sweet, woody, and nutty tone of tonka bean. You can enjoy this long-lasting scent during the colder months, but be aware of the high price.
Anyway, there are many best smelling Carolina Herrera perfumes, including Good Girl. If you want an alluring feminine aroma, you can count on this brand with your eyes closed.
When to Wear
You can use this excellent sweet scent during fall, winter, and spring, both at night and daytime.
Why Should You Buy
- A dupe of Parfums de Marly Carlisle.
- Well-balanced notes.
- Strong sillage.
- 12 hours of longevity.
- A smooth composition.
4. Hafez 1984 Alexandria Fragrances
Those who are into simple and straightforward notes, Hafez 1984 by Alexandria Fragrances will fill all of their boxes. Hany Hafez formulated this cologne in 2018, keeping dedication and hard work in mind.
It begins with the blend of various sweet aromatic accords paired with the richness of tobacco.
Who knew the fruity flavor could be intensified like this?
Then, you will get the sweet, alluring smell of vanilla and exotic spices that lingers on your skin for 12 straight hours with strong sillage.
When to Wear
It’s an ideal cologne for winter and fall nights. During the day, it also works well. The best part is that Hafez 1984 is also wearable during spring.
Why Should You Buy
- Lasts around 12 hours.
- Budget-friendly.
- Strong sillage.
- Suitable for winter.
- A sweet, spicy, dry down.
5. Arrakis Tiziana Terenzi
Top Notes: Osmanthus, Spicy Notes, Saffron, Citruses, Rosemary, Thyme, Grapefruit
Middle Notes: Tobacco, Guaiac Wood, Patchouli, Vetiver
Base Notes: Tonka Bean, Amber, Musk
Arrakis Tiziana Terenzi is another cologne that smells close to Carlisle. The nose behind this replica is Paolo Terenzi. And it came to the market in 2019.
Let’s dive deeper.
At the opening, this unisex fragrance has the perfect mixture of soft, sensual osmanthus with spicy notes. You won’t be able to avoid the herbal and juicy aura of grapefruit and thyme.
Then in the heart, you will encounter the earthy dark smell of patchouli along with a woody tobacco vibe. But for me, tobacco is a no-go.
In the dry down, tonka bean is the most prominent note. Its woody, spicy yet sweet smell mingles with the animalic aura of musk and the cozy, resinous tone of amber in perfect harmony.
Moreover, this scent has 12 hours of longevity, creating a welcoming vibe around you.
When to Wear
Arrakis Tiziana Terenzi casts its magic during winter, spring, and fall, no matter whether it’s night or day.
Why Should You Buy
- Strong sillage.
- Affordable.
- Substitute for Carlisle.
- Long-lasting fragrance.
- A smooth dry down.
6. Patchouli TB Niche4All
Top Notes: Green Apple, Nutmeg
Middle Notes: Tonka Bean, Rose
Base Notes: Vanilla, Patchouli
Patchouli TB Niche4All is a clone of Carlisle launched in 2020. It has the exact notes of the original fragrance. Let’s see how its notes work together.
At the first sniff, you will smell the mesmerizing green apple aroma along with the sweet yet spicy nuance of nutmeg.
As time goes on, the middle becomes more and more vibrant.
The richness of the rose makes the spicy, woody tonka bean more alluring.
And in the dry down, you will be charmed by the harmonious blend of earthy, musky patchouli with the rich sweetness of vanilla. The best part of this scent is its cost-effectiveness and strong sillage.
When to Wear
Patchouli TB Niche4All is ideal for winter and fall nights. If you want, you can wear this woody, spicy fragrance on spring days, too.
Why Should You Buy
- Lasts longer.
- Sillage radiates up to 6 feet.
- A clone of Parfums de Marly Carlisle.
- Good price range.
- A fresh, fruity opening.
Parting Thoughts
Parfums de Marly Carlisle is, without any doubt, a unique fragrance that slowly becomes mind-blowing as time goes on. But due to the high price range, everyone can’t enjoy it.
That’s why I have discussed the best six alternatives that will satisfy your thirst for Carlisle within a reasonable price range.
So, choose your substitute and let me know which one got you carried away. Thanks for engaging.
